Control Which Image Shown in a Note's Thumbnail/Snippet View

[marcelo 48]

I do like the new layout with larger thumbnails, except for one thing: Evernote seems to choose as thumbnail the largest image within a note. But it is rather annoying, for it seldom coincides with the image which would enable me to recognize a note at once. Can I somehow force Evernote to use a specific image as thumbail?

Marcelo

[OneHeWasRubix 6]

I do like the new layout with larger thumbnails, except for one thing: Evernote seems to choose as thumbnail the largest image within a note. But it is rather annoying, for it seldom coincides with the image which would enable me to recognize a note at once. Can I somehow force Evernote to use a specific image as thumbail?

Marcelo

 

 

No.

 

 

This about sums up their response to our user requests.

[allieferr 1]

I've switched from Delicious to Evernote Web Clipper for my bookmarking, and I'm very happy with it so far.

 

However, I wish I could select which image from the web page to use as the Bookmark thumbnail. For instance, when I clipped http://tutorialzine.com/2013/10/12-awesome-css3-features-you-can-finally-use , I got this:

 

 

To me the author's face wasn't a relevant thumbnail for an article about CSS. The web page actually looks like this:

 

 

It would have been great if I could have chosen one of the other graphics from the web page that are more relevant to the content.

[calmriver 7]

+1 ! please add thumbnail image choice !!!!!! 

[leealex 1]

This problem was mention at russian support forum 2 years (TWO YEARS!) ago (06.09.2011) and it still not solved

I doubt developers care about evernote users.

[jbignert 473]

We've noted the request and plan to build it in a not too distant future.

[leealex 1]

We've noted the request and plan to build it in a not too distant future.

Good to hear, hopefully that is true.

[mprewitt 1]

+1. Giving users the ability to choose a thumbnail should be high on Evernote's priority list. The view that shows thumbnails is the default view; browsing notes by title, thumbnail, and snippet is the default behavior. For those reasons alone, being able to choose the thumbnail should be super important. 

 

The current algorithm works sometimes, especially when there is only one or a couple images in a note. But in other situations (for example, when clipping online tutorials which have illustrations of all the steps), the preselected images are nearly worthless. 

 

I have noticed that in certain situations Evernote will pick a different image each time you edit/save the same note. But it doesn't always work to let you choose the image that you prefer. And when it works, it's just another hack to do something that should be as easy as right-click, "Make this my thumbnail". 

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

This feature has been ignored, and frankly I find it unacceptable. Evernote has failed to implement a feature which, from the looks of it, has enough demand to warrant implementation. 

 

We've since moved away from Evernote, and Evernote Business, and have sought after alternatives to this product. Evernote's lack of collaboration tools and features has left us with no choice. Clunky administration, usability failures, and lack of attention to user/client feedback, leaves us no choice but to leave this product and service behind.

 

As a business platform, it completely misses the mark.

 

I'm sure the feature request has not been ignored.  It may be that it's very low on the priority list or that they have decided to not implement it.  Simply because a feature is requested does not mean Evernote (or any other software company) will implement it.

 

 

I do like the new layout with larger thumbnails, except for one thing: Evernote seems to choose as thumbnail the largest image within a note. But it is rather annoying, for it seldom coincides with the image which would enable me to recognize a note at once. Can I somehow force Evernote to use a specific image as thumbail?

Marcelo

 

 

No.

 

 

This about sums up their response to our user requests.

 

 

My reply was to marcelo's specific question that you emphasized - can I somehow force Evernote to use a specific image as a thumbnail?.  As to whether or not the feature request will ever be implemented, there is no way for any of us to know, since Evernote does not publish their roadmap.

[keodark 9]

 

I'm sure the feature request has not been ignored.  It may be that it's very low on the priority list or that they have decided to not implement it.  Simply because a feature is requested does not mean Evernote (or any other software company) will implement it.

 

 

While this is, of course, true, it would be unwise for any software company to ignore [by which I mean set a request very low on the priority list] a vocal community of users. While there may be technological roadblocks to this feature that we are unaware of, a note from a Dev telling us this, and assuring us that they are working to meet our requests would go a long ways towards satisfying us. For example (and this is not vindictive, just a statement of fact), I currently tell my foodie friends not to use Evernote to digitize their cookbook collections, because I did so and it bothers me every day to see incorrectly-chosen thumbnails for all of my recipes. The only thing standing between me and moving my notes away from Evernote is time and motivation, but if this feature isn't implemented, I eventually will do so. I doubt I'm alone.

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

 

 

I'm sure the feature request has not been ignored.  It may be that it's very low on the priority list or that they have decided to not implement it.  Simply because a feature is requested does not mean Evernote (or any other software company) will implement it.

 

 

While this is, of course, true, it would be unwise for any software company to ignore [by which I mean set a request very low on the priority list] a vocal community of users. While there may be technological roadblocks to this feature that we are unaware of, a note from a Dev telling us this, and assuring us that they are working to meet our requests would go a long ways towards satisfying us. For example (and this is not vindictive, just a statement of fact), I currently tell my foodie friends not to use Evernote to digitize their cookbook collections, because I did so and it bothers me every day to see incorrectly-chosen thumbnails for all of my recipes. The only thing standing between me and moving my notes away from Evernote is time and motivation, but if this feature isn't implemented, I eventually will do so. I doubt I'm alone.

 

 

 

We all have to make choices based upon what works for us.  There is no way any company (Evernote included) can satisfy all their users, no matter how vocal they (the users) are.  Certainly those requesting nested notebooks are at least as vocal as the "choosing my own thumbnail" camp & probably even for a longer period of time.  And yet, Evernote has no nested notebooks nor any indication that particular feature is in the pipeline.  Again, it's not that they are "ignoring" their users.  Choices & priorities must be made.  This feature is something that is a high priority to you & some others.  I could not care less.  Someone else will have yet another feature/fix that is the highest priority for them.  Such is life.  The rule of thumb that has been posted here many times is to deal with Evernote as it works now, rather than anticipating any future features.  If it does not work for you now & you cannot or will not adjust your workflow to make it so, then another app is probably better suited to you.

 

BTW, if I were one of your foodie friends, I would resent you telling me to not use EN Food simply b/c you're not happy with it.  Especially since your decision is based on the thumbnail (per your post).  I'm certainly capable of making my own decisions & knowing what works best for me.  So unless your friends are not capable of making their own decisions, you may simply want to express your dissatisfaction with Evernote to them & let them decide for themselves, rather than telling them not to use it.

[keodark 9]

There is no way any company (Evernote included) can satisfy all their users, no matter how vocal they (the users) are.  Certainly those requesting nested notebooks are at least as vocal as the "choosing my own thumbnail" camp & probably even for a longer period of time.  And yet, Evernote has no nested notebooks nor any indication that particular feature is in the pipeline.  Again, it's not that they are "ignoring" their users.  Choices & priorities must be made.  This feature is something that is a high priority to you & some others.  I could not care less.  Someone else will have yet another feature/fix that is the highest priority for them.  Such is life.  The rule of thumb that has been posted here many times is to deal with Evernote as it works now, rather than anticipating any future features.  If it does not work for you now & you cannot or will not adjust your workflow to make it so, then another app is probably better suited to you.

 

BTW, if I were one of your foodie friends, I would resent you telling me to not use EN Food.  Especially since your decision is based on the thumbnail.  I'm certainly capable of making my own decisions & knowing what works best for me.  So unless your friends are not capable of making their own decisions, you may simply want to express your dissatisfaction with Evernote to them, rather than telling them not to use it.

 

 

Yes, so let us all curl up in a ball and keep our requests to ourselves, because not standing up and asking for things is how you get what you want in life. If Evernote is like every other software company in the world, then they have a list of feature requests, and the order that those requests get completed is directly correlated to how "vocal" the community is in asking for them. Evernote is not in business to do whatever the hell it wants, it's in business to make money by providing software that people want to use. People want thumbnail selection, and every voice that adds itself to this discussion is contributing to the demand for that feature. End. Of. Story.

 

Also I don't TELL people not to use Evernote, I simply share my experience with them, and suggest that the thumbnail feature is something that makes for an unsatisfactory digital cookbook. Most people are grateful for the advice.

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

Yes, so let us all curl up in a ball and keep our requests to ourselves, because not standing up and asking for things is how you get what you want in life. If Evernote is like every other software company in the world, then they have a list of feature requests, and the order that those requests get completed is directly correlated to how "vocal" the community is in asking for them. Evernote is not in business to do whatever the hell it wants, it's in business to make money by providing software that people want to use. People want thumbnail selection, and every voice that adds itself to this discussion is contributing to the demand for that feature. End. Of. Story.

 

Also I don't TELL people not to use Evernote, I simply share my experience with them, and suggest that the thumbnail feature is something that makes for an unsatisfactory digital cookbook. Most people are grateful for the advice.

Oh please. No one has said you shouldn't ask for a feature.  But you seem to think b/c a feature has been asked for & not implemented that you are being ignored, which is simply not true.  I've pretty much said all there is to say on this topic.  You can learn from it or not. 

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

Also I don't TELL people not to use Evernote,

Well, I guess I misunderstood this then..

I currently tell my foodie friends not to use Evernote to digitize their cookbook collections,

[keodark 9]

 

Also I don't TELL people not to use Evernote,

Well, I guess I misunderstood this then..

I currently tell my foodie friends not to use Evernote to digitize their cookbook collections,

 

 

I didn't realize my words would be picked apart and analyzed, frankly. I was using a pretty common shorthand, "tell", a verb used often to convey that a conversation took place. Forgive me, please, for using a slightly less-than-perfect word.

[Yahenda 6]

Every once in a while, I stop by this forum to see if any progress has been made in regards to this feature request over the last nearly two and a half years that I've been following it. It's the one missing feature that has kept me from adopting Evernote.

This time, I decided to try something... I used the Evernote web clipper to clip the first page from this discusison and add it to my notebook... I used 'Clip Whole Page' rather than 'Clip article' and when I went to my notebook using my browser... guess what the auto-selected thumbnail for the note was... the default blank member avatar.

I tried it again with the last page of the discussion thus far... just to see if it would be any different or anymore useful... this time, the mighty algorithm auto-selected... member mprewitt's avatar of a cube floating in blue space.

In my notebook's snippets view, the Evernote logo is nowhere to be seen and according to the algorithm, completely non-viable as a choice.

...Now, is there a cleverly written algorithm to select whether this is hilarious, ironic or just sad? (sorry, I just had to ;p )



Still ready to come back to Evernote the moment they impliment user selected thumbnails,

Yahenda
 

[leticia 0]

Just wanted to add to the list of people who really need this simple feature.

 

I really try to love Evernote, I think it's a very clever app with amazing potential, but unfortunately I go back and forth using it for a while and then giving up, because when seemingly small features like this are missing it's very hard to manage so much information in a productive way. They may seem small, but when you have a hundred small issues it can really render the app useless.

 

It's a shame.

[Evernotester 0]

Please add this feature. It is such a useful feature that it is unbelieveable it isn't there from first.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

I can't believe that the obvious feature to select your own thumbnail picture is still not implemented. It just shows that Evernote is not listening to its customers. It should be a piece of cake to add that feature... 

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I can't believe that the obvious feature to select your own thumbnail picture is still not implemented. It just shows that Evernote is not listening to its customers. It should be a piece of cake to add that feature...

Whether it's a piece of cake to implement is not something you can speak to unless you are intimate with Evernote under the hood & how it behaves on the various other platforms. Additionally, there are a lot of feature requests by the 60+ million users. The fact that *your* feature request has not been implemented is no indication that EN is not listening to their customers. Sometimes a feature is simply something EN has decided to not implement at all. Or perhaps it's a lower priority than a lot of other things.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

 

I can't believe that the obvious feature to select your own thumbnail picture is still not implemented. It just shows that Evernote is not listening to its customers. It should be a piece of cake to add that feature...

Whether it's a piece of cake to implement is not something you can speak to unless you are intimate with Evernote under the hood & how it behaves on the various other platforms. Additionally, there are a lot of feature requests by the 60+ million users. The fact that *your* feature request has not been implemented is no indication that EN is not listening to their customers. Sometimes a feature is simply something EN has decided to not implement at all. Or perhaps it's a lower priority than a lot of other things.

 

 

"Evangelapologist" seems to describe you very well, indeed!

 

Custom thumbnail selection would be one of the most important features to organize your notes and quickly find what you are looking for. After all, a picture says more than a thousand words.

 

If Evernote cannot implement something as basic as this, they should go out of business. End of story...

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I can't believe that the obvious feature to select your own thumbnail picture is still not implemented. It just shows that Evernote is not listening to its customers. It should be a piece of cake to add that feature...

Whether it's a piece of cake to implement is not something you can speak to unless you are intimate with Evernote under the hood & how it behaves on the various other platforms. Additionally, there are a lot of feature requests by the 60+ million users. The fact that *your* feature request has not been implemented is no indication that EN is not listening to their customers. Sometimes a feature is simply something EN has decided to not implement at all. Or perhaps it's a lower priority than a lot of other things.

 

"Evangelapologist" seems to describe you very well, indeed!

 

Custom thumbnail selection would be one of the most important features to organize your notes and quickly find what you are looking for. After all, a picture says more than a thousand words.

 

If Evernote cannot implement something as basic as this, they should go out of business. End of story...

Thumbnail selection is certainly not the most important feature for many people, including me. End of story.

[megsaint 441]

Custom thumbnail selection would be one of the most important features to organize your notes and quickly find what you are looking for. After all, a picture says more than a thousand words.

It might be important to you but personally, I really don't care. Now, the ability to sort each notebook individually, now THAT'S important!

[JMichaelTX 4,093]

While it is true that it is hard for anyone who is not an Evernote developer to know exactly how hard it is to implement a specific feature, it is possible for a person who has substantial experience as a software developer to make a reasonable, educated guess concerning the relative difficulty of making a small change.

 

In this case the change is NOT about setting some internal field which tells the software which image to use as a thumbnail.  That has already been done.  And, in fact, the developers have already discussed in these forums the very complex logic which is used to select the image to be used.  I, for one, believe that it is reasonable to assume that it does not take a huge amount of effort to add a menu option to the right-click (context) menu to allow the user to select the image to be used.  I can say this because, as a develper, I have written code for this type of UI many times.  It is also clear that the current complex code that is used to select the image does something to set the internal field.  So, the only real change that is needed is that which allows the user to select the image.  All off the remaining code that processes that result is already in place and should be able to be used with little effort.

 

But I digress.  It seems to be of little value to raise objections to a user's request simply because the user thinks it may or may not be difficult to implement.  That is not a question that we can settle here.  So, IMO, the best course of action is to ignore the user's opinion of difficulty of implementation, and focus on the usefulness of the requested feature.

 

Frankly I can't imagine why anyone would object to this feature.  Today's web pages contain 10's, if not 100's, of images, especially when you remember all the ads that are so commonplace.  IMO it is highly unlikely that any algorithm could determine which one of these many images is most relevant to the user who captured the web page.  So providing for a user selected image for the thumbnail is most logical.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

I have to laugh about the fanboys here...

 

Having a user defined option for the thumbnail is just another field that has to be added to the database. If it's populated, tell the software to use that field, if it's empty, use the standard field that is populated by the algorithm. Any IT developer worth his salt can add that feature in half a day. This is not some Google-type complex machine-learning stuff, this is just totally basic and it is ridiculous that it hasn't been an option from day one or implemented in the meantime.

 

This thread was started in July 2011 and we now have almost 2014. Has Evernote ever heard of agile software development??? Something smells here...

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I have to laugh about the fanboys here...

 

Having a user defined option for the thumbnail is just another field that has to be added to the database. If it's populated, tell the software to use that field, if it's empty, use the standard field that is populated by the algorithm. Any IT developer worth his salt can add that feature in half a day. This is not some Google-type complex machine-learning stuff, this is just totally basic and it is ridiculous that it hasn't been an option from day one or implemented in the meantime.

 

This thread was started in July 2011 and we now have almost 2014. Has Evernote ever heard of agile software development??? Something smells here...

 

 

Yeah, I wondered how long it would be before you dug up the F word.  That seems to be the go to word when someone can't accept that others have valid opinions that differ from theirs.  If I don't agree with you, then I must be a fanboy.  Sweet.

 

BTW, since it's clear you don't get it, that's why I have evangapologist in my tag line.  It's called sarcasm.

 

And please re-read my earlier post, since you seem to have blinders on as to why this feature may not be implemented. 

 

This really isn't worth debating, since the bottom line is that it really doesn't matter what you or I think.  The issue has been presented to EN & they either will or will not implement it based upon *their* criteria.  If it's a deal breaker for you & you have so little regard for the developers based upon the fact that your "go to" feature has not been implemented, then you should be disgusted & find an app that better suits your needs.  Good luck.

 

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

Frankly I can't imagine why anyone would object to this feature.

Please point out where anyone has objected to this feature.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

 

 

BTW, since it's clear you don't get it, that's why I have evangapologist in my tag line.  It's called sarcasm.

 

 

 

As an "Evangelapologist" you are an Evangelist and an Apologist. I don't like either.

 

Nuff said...

[jefito 5,542]

This thread was started in July 2011 and we now have almost 2014. Has Evernote ever heard of agile software development??? Something smells here...

At a guess, they have heard of agile software development, and I believe that they practice some form of it (I don't know that they are true religious adherents, but frequent, semi-regular updates do give evidence for some agilistic process). Just a reminder, though -- the agile methodology doesn't tell you to implement all features that are desired; it just offers a way to deliver desired improvements in a more timely and continuous fashion, but doesn't specify which of those improvements are chosen or how they're prioritized.

On another note: let's everybody bring this discussion back to a more civil and constructive place, please.

[Geoff Olynyk 1]

Just chiming in to add that I would also really, really like this feature. Been waiting for it for a year now. It would also be useful because sometimes when creating a note through the web interface on a slow connection, no thumbnail is created, and I would like to be able to create one manually later. Thanks!

[knottychic 0]

I'd also love to have this feature.  Thanks!

[Jackolicious 808]

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

[Geoff Olynyk 1]

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

 

Thanks for the reply! I definitely appreciate the complexity of making these changes. Glad to know that it's on your list, at least!

[keodark 9]

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

 

Thanks, Jackolicious, for replying to this thread. Glad to know it's on the radar. I hope nobody is truly belittling the work necessary here, although I personally think the feature is important enough to justify the effort. As a software engineer working on a large-scale production environment, I understand the complexities involved. I'd like to think that this is primarily a user interface issue (since the thumbnail selection is already stored in the DB), and only the method of choosing (and changing) that thumbnail is what's being asked for. Nevertheless, I appreciate the work you guys do. Cheers!

[nycbrown 0]

+1

[HuggyTheBear 4]

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

 

Actually, it would be really interesting to read an in-depth explanation of why this is so complex. I understand that you have billions of notes on your servers, but you won't have to adjust all those notes, if you allow the user to override your algo-determined thumbnail. I would be all ears to understand that problem better...

[jefito 5,542]

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

 

Actually, it would be really interesting to read an in-depth explanation of why this is so complex. I understand that you have billions of notes on your servers, but you won't have to adjust all those notes, if you allow the user to override your algo-determined thumbnail. I would be all ears to understand that problem better...

You should probably take Jack up on his offer, and open a new topic.

[a3chic9 1]

I'd like to add my +1 for this feature. I'd especially love it because those images are used in Evernote food.

[linaz 1]

I am new to Evernote and this was the first feature that I noticed was missing. It's a deal breaker for me at this point. I was thrilled to find something I could use across platforms that met all my other requirements. It looks like I'll be back when the "fix is in."

[ramzez1974 0]

I found a a easy way to change the thumbnail in my iMac (sorry I don't use Evernote in Windows) I am using version 5.4.4 (402231)

Choose the image you want use as a thumbnail within Evernote by highlighting it (it becomes light blue).

Open with preview.

Resize the image and save the file.

In my experimenting I increased the image to150% of the original size.

But it does not affect how it is displayed in Evernote.

The thumbnail is immediately changed when the size fits the thumbnail algorithm described earlier in this thread.

 

I only tried this once. But I am sure this will solve this once and for all.

[MacProCT 4]

Evernote, please add the ability for me to specify the thumbnail for my notes.  I don't like the way the "automatic" selection algorithm works and I wish to be in control of what I see.  Thank you.

[buffal0gal 7]

YES  please!!!.  The largest smallest algorythm sucks for most of my notes.  It's fine to leave that as the default, but allow me to change WHICH image in a note is the thumbnail. Even if that editing ability is only in the desktop version.

 

PLEASE!!!!

[Stoic 4]

Please implement something for this. Pretty please!    (Made a form account just to say that...)

[andyddd 1]

FEATURE REQUEST:
 

Default Thumbnail Generation:

  Position:  (*) Largest-Smallest    ( ) Whole Page
                   (  ) Specific:  [(*) Top   ( ) Middle   ( ) Bottom]  [(*) Left   ( ) Center   ( ) Right]
 

  Page:  (*) First Page   ( ) Last Page   ( ) Specific Page:  [   1] (or last if page count too small)
 

    [Apply to Future Notes Only]     [Apply to All Notes Now^*]

              ^*Apply to All Notes Now may take a very long time.

[JMichaelTX 4,093]

I'd be happy if I could just right-click on an image in the Note, and select it as the thumbnail.

[cbits 12]

I have just been reading pages about this... quite unbelievable that Evernote should make such a mess up of something so simple as having a "Choose" featured image" - all Wordpress Blog posts have this it's very simple and if people don't choose one the program picks one, whether it uses some "largest, mines bigger than yours, tiniest"  consideration I neither know nor care.

 

I suspect the quote "You don't have to like it, but that's the way it is. (shrug)" from one of your evangelists is a very good indication of the Evernote attitude to it's customers and their requirements.

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I have just been reading pages about this... quite unbelievable that Evernote should make such a mess up of something so simple as having a "Choose" featured image" - all Wordpress Blog posts have this it's very simple and if people don't choose one the program picks one, whether it uses some "largest, mines bigger than yours, tiniest" consideration I neither know nor care.

I suspect the quote "You don't have to like it, but that's the way it is. (shrug)" from one of your evangelists is a very good indication of the Evernote attitude to it's customers and their requirements.

No, it's not simple. Clearly you overlooked this post (by a Evernote employee) in the thread....

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

[mike77n 2]

It would be very usable feature in my view. it's difficult to make a notebook visual now - main reason for I had to move some of my stuff to Springpad.

[saintleighjess 39]

REQUEST – It would be amazing to have a feature where an image can be selected, and when you right-click (ie, the same way you rotate it, etc.) there could also be an option to override the "largest smallest-dimension" algorithm and set that image as the note's thumbnail.

A little background –– 

One thing I use EN for very heavily is as an artist database for my job. I really like having both a photo of the artist and an example of their artwork at the top of their card.

However, when I'm scrolling through snippet or card view, it would be really helpful to have the image of their artwork always be the one to show up. This usually happens but there are a few times where the photo of the artist is used instead.

I've read up on the algorithm that chooses the image with the "largest smallest-dimension" (PS, see what I did there with the hyphen? Way clearer that way.) and I am actually OCD enough to try to amend the file sizes to have the algorithm pick the right one. However, even this doesn't seem to work – it's probably me because I guess an algorithm can't lie, but even when I resize the images, it's still not choosing the right one.

So my question is – why would that be happening? Could it be that once EN's algorithm chooses an image, it always chooses that filename even when the size changes?

But what would be SO MUCH EASIER is my *request* – could there be an override option to the largest smallest-dimension algorithm (which I agree does work at least half of the time for me) to choose a thumbnail? I'm not talking some fancy thing in the settings where you tell EN how to pick your thumbnails – that sounds like way more work than it's worth. I just imagine, like I've said above, having the image you want to be the thumbnail highlighted/selected, then right click (in the same way that you can rotate an image, etc.) and have something like "set as note thumbnail."

Please??

Thank you!

[saintleighjess 39]

I've read some earlier posts about this problem, but I want to bring it up again and also offer another suggestion for a solution. 

 

I want to reiterate that it's really frustrating to not be able to choose a thumbnail photo. One of the things I use EN very heavily for is as a database of artists for my job. Each artist has a card and I like to have a photo of them and an example of their artwork. Both images are important to me and to the database's function, but it would be hugely helpful if the thumbnail for each card in snippet view was the artist's artwork, not their photo – since when I'm scrolling in that view it's the style of artwork I'm scanning for. 

 

I agree with the developers that the "largest smallest-dimension" algorithm does work a lot of the time, but it doesn't always, and it's a huge pain to try to resize images to get them in the correct ratio. I am super OCD about things like that and I've tried but actually have given up. 

 

I'm not suggesting a fancy option in the settings that creates a rule for how EN chooses the thumbnail – that sounds like way too much development work and I totally appreciate that (1) the thumbnail doesn't matter that much in a lot of cases and (2) it would cause a lot of issues with webpage banners, etc. 

 

My request is to create an option when the image is selected and right-clicked in desktop version (i.e. like how you rotate the image) that is something like "set image as thumbnail." I hope that this could be a good compromise solution to this issue that wouldn't pose the same difficulties as creating a series of complicated rules in settings, but would still allow users flexibility and control in selecting a thumbnail when it does actually matter a lot. 

 

Thank you! 

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I've merged the two threads you started. Please do not start multiple threads on the same topic. Thank you.

[saintleighjess 39]

I've merged the two threads you started. Please do not start multiple threads on the same topic. Thank you.

 

Sorry that was an accident! I retyped for nothing, bummer. On a train and the wifi is really shoddy.

 

You can just delete the first one that lost all its formatting etc. – I can't figure out how to do it. 

[Doug C. 8]

Well it's been three years and this still isn't implemented and Evernote continues to pick the wrong thumbnail.  So is this going to be fixed any time soon?  I can't even seem to cut/copy an image from Evernote and paste it into an image editing program, so perhaps that can be fixed too. Seems odd to have a native app that fails the basic rules for a native app.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

Well it's been three years and this still isn't implemented and Evernote continues to pick the wrong thumbnail.  So is this going to be fixed any time soon?  I can't even seem to cut/copy an image from Evernote and paste it into an image editing program, so perhaps that can be fixed too. Seems odd to have a native app that fails the basic rules for a native app.

 

I guess that is called "agile software development" ;-)

[chronistin 178]

Well it's been three years and this still isn't implemented and Evernote continues to pick the wrong thumbnail.  So is this going to be fixed any time soon?  I can't even seem to cut/copy an image from Evernote and paste it into an image editing program, so perhaps that can be fixed too. Seems odd to have a native app that fails the basic rules for a native app.

 

I don't know which client you are using, but in windows you can rightclick any image and select "open with..." to choose an image editing program to edit the pic.

 

Also, EN does not pick the "wrong" thumbnail, it picks the thumbnail it is designed to pick. I would also like to choose my own thumbnail, but words are important, too.

[jefito 5,542]

 

Well it's been three years and this still isn't implemented and Evernote continues to pick the wrong thumbnail.  So is this going to be fixed any time soon?  I can't even seem to cut/copy an image from Evernote and paste it into an image editing program, so perhaps that can be fixed too. Seems odd to have a native app that fails the basic rules for a native app.

 

I guess that is called "agile software development" ;-)

 

Cute, but agile software development doesn't mean that all requested features are delivered...

[jbenson2 2,133]

Just a reminder:

 

Evernote's actual description of their head-scratching "Largest-Smallest" image selection algorithm:

 

http://discussion.evernote.com/topic/18482-choosing-a-thumbnail/page__view__findpost__p__92194

[JMichaelTX 4,093]

It's interesting.  The thumbnail in the Snippet view was the BIG thing Evernote promoted when the Snippet view was released, quite some time ago.  
 
But the problem is that their algorithm often doesn't select what the user would have selected to represent the Note.  Even Evernote/emerick admitted it's shortcomings:
 
 

I think we're reasonably happy with the algorithm we're using; they're all subject to false positives, unfortunately, but I think our algorithm ends up choosing a fairly representative image a lot of the time.

The problem is when the Evernote algorithm chooses an image that has nothing to do with the Note -- this is actually misleading and may cause the user to skip over that Note when he/she is visually scanning for a certain Note.

 

IOW, the thumbnail is supposed to HELP us find the Note we want, but in some cases, about 30-40% of my cases, it actually misdirects/misleads us.

 

That's why allowing the user to do a simple right-click on the image and select "Choose thumbnail" would be so great!

[mr. melancholy 5]

Simple solution... Choose the first picture, image or photo as thumbnail. As long as we have NO control over it. Why on earth make it so complex. 

 

Forget the ridiculous largest smallest or whatever.

[Esben Sæderup 0]

I agree...

Professionalism >>

If the people behind Evernote handels customer feedback in a professional manner - Going through this tread, makes it very clear, that this issue has to be addressed.

If a code-designer - in an effort to address this issue - considers a change in 'algorithm' - to simply selecting the first image - to be a task too complicated, either the code is a complete mess, or the code-designer is no longer acting professionally...

°

°

°

The Reason and the Why >>

I can only guess, as to what the possible causes for something like this might be, but imagine that whoever created the current 'algorithm', also promoted this idea in a discussion with his or her coworkers (since anyone using Evernote on a regular basis, would quickly notice this issue) - now that code-designer is emotionally involved in the final outcome of this discussion/request, and might regard a code-re-design, as a personal admission to failure.

I find it very hard to believe, that the main obstacles are technical in nature. For a problem - apparently going back several years now - I would have expected a post from someone within the company, explaining the obstacles involved in a re-design of the code or algorithm, in order to get some concrete suggestions to possible solutions, or at least reassure free-users and paying customers that an effort is being made.

Since a thorough & professional response - to the request of Change - has not been made, my best guess is that the obstacles are psychological in nature.

°

°

°

Solution (The First Step) >>

The code-designing of the Evernote software, is probably divided into several teams, where each employee is designated an "area of expertise".

So bear in mind, that this discussion/request might very well be followed by only a few, or maybe just one Evernote employee.

Since this tread - at the moment - appears to result in nothing, the best way to improve the chances of a fix, would be to increase the internal awareness - of this tread and the Picture-Preview-Issue - within the Evernote Corporation, by sending a link to this discussion/request to different areas of support, and ask why nothing is being done >>IMPORTANT>> you should only send the link and the question one time, to each different line of support, and make it as Short as possible, don't spam, and keep it constructive...

The more Different people who do this, the better will the chances be, of creating a constructive internal pressure towards a fix, by increasing awareness, as to how many dedicated users (which you must be, if you read this far) actually recognize the current Picture-Preview-Function as inappropriate.

Overall, I think their services include many great tools for organising, research and sharing, and a possible fix to the discussed issue, would be a very useful improvement to Evernote.

Good luck (if you need it)

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

I agree...

Professionalism >>

If the people behind Evernote handels customer feedback in a professional manner - Going through this tread, makes it very clear, that this issue has to be addressed.

If a code-designer - in an effort to address this issue - considers a change in 'algorithm' - to simply selecting the first image - to be a task too complicated, either the code is a complete mess, or the code-designer is no longer acting professionally...

°

°

°

The Reason and the Why >>

I can only guess, as to what the possible causes for something like this might be, but imagine that whoever created the current 'algorithm', also promoted this idea in a discussion with his or her coworkers (since anyone using Evernote on a regular basis, would quickly notice this issue) - now that code-designer is emotionally involved in the final outcome of this discussion/request, and might regard a code-re-design, as a personal admission to failure.

I find it very hard to believe, that the main obstacles are technical in nature. For a problem - apparently going back several years now - I would have expected a post from someone within the company, explaining the obstacles involved in a re-design of the code or algorithm, in order to get some concrete suggestions to possible solutions, or at least reassure free-users and paying customers that an effort is being made.

Since a thorough & professional response - to the request of Change - has not been made, my best guess is that the obstacles are psychological in nature.

°

°

°

Solution (The First Step) >>

The code-designing of the Evernote software, is probably divided into several teams, where each employee is designated an "area of expertise".

So bear in mind, that this discussion/request might very well be followed by only a few, or maybe just one Evernote employee.

Since this tread - at the moment - appears to result in nothing, the best way to improve the chances of a fix, would be to increase the internal awareness - of this tread and the Picture-Preview-Issue - within the Evernote Corporation, by sending a link to this discussion/request to different areas of support, and ask why nothing is being done >>IMPORTANT>> you should only send the link and the question one time, to each different line of support, and make it as Short as possible, don't spam, and keep it constructive...

The more Different people who do this, the better will the chances be, of creating a constructive internal pressure towards a fix, by increasing awareness, as to how many dedicated users (which you must be, if you read this far) actually recognize the current Picture-Preview-Function as inappropriate.

Overall, I think their services include many great tools for organising, research and sharing, and a possible fix to the discussed issue, would be a very useful improvement to Evernote.

Good luck (if you need it)

The requests for this feature have definitely been noted and I appreciate the spirited discussion!

 

Just as a point of reference, describing the complexity of this task as "small" or assuming that it would "only take half a day" is grossly underestimating the level of effort involved in modifying a database structure supporting 80 million users (and billions of notes) in a production environment Happy to discuss this further with anyone in a separate thread!

[Esben Sæderup 0]

Understood, but the post you're citing from "Jackolicious", is more than 5 months old... do you have any updated information on the current status, the main obstacles, and the - hopefully near - future forecasts/expectations regarding the Picture-Preview-Issue?

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

Understood, but the post you're citing from "Jackolicious", is more than 5 months old... do you have any updated information on the current status, the main obstacles, and the - hopefully near - future forecasts/expectations regarding the Picture-Preview-Issue?

This is a users board. EN staff post occasionally. And EN does not publish their roadmap or ETAs.

[brookslu 1]

YES! This would be so helpful.  I use Evernote as a database to keep track of my sewing patterns.  Each note has a image of the front of the pattern (completed item picture), and the back of the pattern (words/numbers).  When the back of the pattern ends up as the thumbnail, it's pretty useless as a way to quickly browse through to see what I have.  Hopefully that explanation made sense.  It would be a lot easier to just pick which picture to have as a thumbnail than to have to manually go and resize images. 

[matthieu. 4]

I also need this feature, please.

 

And to avoid this kind of thread, with a lot of misunderstanding, I think Evernote should publish their roadmap, so we can estimate what will be available in near future. And perhaps also add a votebox like Dropbox had before, to allow users to prioritize new features.

 

I'm now a paying customer, and as I really LOVE Evernote, I want it better, and I want to use it for more task than now 

[RJRJ 3]

please do it!
I even interrupted  my paid subscription this year because of this problem.
I have 800 notes, and thumbnails for each of them are different on all my devices.
I'm tired, it's very difficult to perception!

[Inspector Gadget 2]

This is a seriously overdue fix and a big design limitation.  

 

People have been complaining about this topic on this thread since 2011.  

 

What is taking Evernote so long?  How complex can this be?

[HuggyTheBear 4]

I guess that the guy who wrote the selection algorithm is so pissed off that people hate it that he blocks any change. Or he has left and the others have no clue how to fix it. Or they are lazy. Or they are stupid. Or they don't care. Or they are busy playing online games or having ***** in the office. Or they are watching Breaking Bad all day long. Or (well, make up your own reason).

 

Anyway, hell will freeze over before we will get that feature...

[JMichaelTX 4,093]

@HuggyTheBear, I'm not sure if you intended it this way, but your post brought a smile to my face.  A little humor goes a long way.  

[jefito 5,542]

I guess that the guy who wrote the selection algorithm is so pissed off that people hate it that he blocks any change. Or he has left and the others have no clue how to fix it. Or they are lazy. Or they are stupid. Or they don't care. Or they are busy playing online games or having ***** in the office. Or they are watching Breaking Bad all day long. Or (well, make up your own reason).

Cute, but the usual answer in the real world is that the folks who make decisions about what to implement don't see it as a high priority item. I suppose that could count as "they don't care" or "they don't care enough about the issue to change the behavior".

[HuggyTheBear 4]

 

Cute, but the usual answer in the real world is that the folks who make decisions about what to implement don't see it as a high priority item. 

 

In that case they are stupid since it is such an important and obvious feature and it beggars believe that it wasn't implemented from day one.

 

BTW, since when is listening to your customers a bad idea? Companies like Salesforce grow like gangbusters because they do exactly that. Others fall by the wayside...

 

Finally, I have never encountered a user forum where so called "Evangelists" defend each and every stupidity of a company. Really strange sect-like behavior here that even Apple can't match.

[Inspector Gadget 2]

 

Cute, but the usual answer in the real world is that the folks who make decisions about what to implement don't see it as a high priority item. I suppose that could count as "they don't care" or "they don't care enough about the issue to change the behavior".

 

 

Ah, yes, asking users is so tedious. 

 

My favorite response to this thread was early one when an apparent developer explained that Evernote selects the image with the "biggest smallest dimension."  HAHAHAHA.  

 

I plan to use that as a fantastic example of exceptionally poor human design. The analogy for bad machine programming would be writing code instructing the system to select the "coolest image."  

[BurgersNFries 2,406]

 

 

Cute, but the usual answer in the real world is that the folks who make decisions about what to implement don't see it as a high priority item. I suppose that could count as "they don't care" or "they don't care enough about the issue to change the behavior".

 

 

Ah, yes, asking users is so tedious. 

 

My favorite response to this thread was early one when an apparent developer explained that Evernote selects the image with the "biggest smallest dimension."  HAHAHAHA.  

 

I plan to use that as a fantastic example of exceptionally poor human design. The analogy for bad machine programming would be writing code instructing the system to select the "coolest image."  

 

 

I don't recall 'tedious' being stated as to why they don't ask their users.  But clearly, EN does not see this as a high priority.  Debating why is pointless. 

[jefito 5,542]

In that case they are stupid since it is such an important and obvious feature and it beggars believe that it wasn't implemented from day one.

 

BTW, since when is listening to your customers a bad idea? Companies like Salesforce grow like gangbusters because they do exactly that. Others fall by the wayside...

 

Finally, I have never encountered a user forum where so called "Evangelists" defend each and every stupidity of a company. Really strange sect-like behavior here that even Apple can't match.

I'm not defending Evernote at all, I'm just pointing out a reality of software development, or indeed, development of any product or service. You take request, mix them in with your own ideas, try to figure out level-of-effort vs perceived benefit, sort against other features, and lay them out against available resources. This article is an interesting read in that light, at least to me.  Please point out where I say that it's a bad idea to listen to your customers. It's always fair for users to make requests (and I believe that does Evernote listen), but those requests compete for resources with other users' requests, and Evernote's internal plans for their products.

 

For what it's worth, I see this feature as a nice-to-have for my use case, as opposed to "important and obvious", but that's independent of what I was saying when I replied to you.

[HuggyTheBear 4]

Here can read what Evernote is up to: http://www.fastcompany.com/3034378/most-innovative-companies/evernotes-secret-to-getting-free-users-to-pony-up

 

Talking about getting your priorities wrong...

[Metrodon 2,155]

Here can read what Evernote is up to: http://www.fastcompany.com/3034378/most-innovative-companies/evernotes-secret-to-getting-free-users-to-pony-up

 

Talking about getting your priorities wrong...

The Market is hardly a secret, in fact it's a very profitable product line.

I don't understand why this is them getting their priorities wrong? For Evernote to be around for a long time, to continue making useful software it has to be profitable, Market contributes to this.

It's not like the Xcode developers are whittling the pen pots is it?

Whether you think the products are any good or decent value for money is a personal thing, but I very much doubt that the technical team are in any way affected by the Market with the exception of products like the scanner and moleskine that have proved to be very successful.

[LukVL 15]

Hello,

 

I had a lot of notes about "people", say an employee-database or the members of an organisation.

One picture and a lot of other data (birthday, telephone-number...)

I loved it, I had the data everywhere, on my Iphone, Ipad, PC..

One look at Evernote, and I saw the picture of the person, and his name in the thumnail form.

 

Yesterday, I added for every person a scanned report, and I can't see the pictures of the people, but a completely unnessesary report that is downsized to thumbnail format so that every report looks the same. 

Do I really have to resize all my pictures to get them on the thumbnail?

What a waste of time AND a waste of server-space.

I don't like that anymore. I'll search for an other program, bye bye Evernote.

 

How can smart people come to such an algorithm?

How does it come that it takes so much time (years) to "repair" such an obvious mistake??

 

I think it is time to write a few comments in IT-literature about this.

 

Best regards

[cbits 12]

I'm with Yahenda on this point.

I've been watching this topic for over a year, with debates about "largest, smallest sides" etc. how anal can you get?

 

The issue here isn't complex; "set featured image", Wordpress can do it, Google+ can do it, FB can do it Twitter can do it, I can do it in an email, but EVERNOTE can't manage it??

 

Cumon guys you do unending updates for differences I cannot see, but something many customers want and no-one is going to argue against,?

Use whatever algorithms you want, it's hugely unimportant, BUT let me override them to say "I want to use this image"

 

Or do you really think so little of your customers?

[HuggyTheBear 4]

 

Or do you really think so little of your customers?

 

Dude, they are currently working on an algorithm that deletes all the nude pictures of Jennifer Lawrence that people have saved. That's more important than solving the thumbnail issue ;-)

[cbits 12]

Jennifer Lawrence ?? who is Jennifer Lawrence ??

My nude piccies are of Bill Gates, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, and some guy called Obama something, or other,

but don't worry Evernote will never find them cos I cant set them as "featured image"

[atodwe 3]

This has been my main issue with Evernote since becoming a very early adopter. I am an artist and a designer and Evernote's visual aspect is part of what makes Evernote work for me over other solutions. Yet the inability to choose the thumbnail is completely at odds with this core nature of the app. In my experience, and from what I have read in how-to recommendations, using Evernote as frequently and deeply as possible is the way to get the most out of it. With a high volume of notes, trying to think about algorithms about "largest of smallest dimensions" of the images in the note is not possible. It is too confusing and and to open and resize all one's images, calculating a dimension strategy, would just take too much time.

 

I love TheBrain software; I think the system of forming relationships between notes/thoughts is very compelling and useful, and it has many capabilities and features. I also love the look of it. But the one reason I have a hard time using it as my primary note/thought repository is that the interface is, ultimately, not visual enough for me. I want to scan through my notes and see a visual representation, not just a title. Evernote is better on this score, even without the ability to choose thumbnails. But Evernote would be so much more successful with that feature.

 

Evernote, is there any chance you are working on the addition of this feature? I throw in my strong request that you do.

 

Please!

 

Thanks!! 

[Spectrablue 2]

I too need to select which of two images in my note are the thumbnail. I would also like to see the image chosen shrunk to fit the default thumbnail image and not see evidence of cropping. Or let me choose to crop or not to crop as long as you care about giving me thumbnail edit experiences. 

 

I have bought the evernote scanner... I'll be scanning over 13,000 art cards from FPG, Comic Images and the like. I've scanned about 6500 so far. Each card has a front and back image. In theory the size of the images should be the same as its just front and back of the same physical card as it rolls through the Evernote (Fujitsu) scanner. The outcome of which image is selected for the thumbnail in my experience with ties is just bizarre. The front of the card typically is the first image (assuming I correctly inserted the card stack in the scanner) and has an artistic image on it. The back image is text describing the image on the front along with a numbering schema. Obviously I would like the first art image to be the thumbnail. Alas, I'm stuck with all the other users who look at this situation in total bewilderment. Frankly all these images are also uploaded to Google drive and presented via Google plus and managed via Google picasa. Ultimately the tools in Picasa and Google Plus photos allow me to do what I need. Yet Evernote was so close yet so far away due to this feature. Presentation mode almost allowed me to do what I wanted but they insisted upon the header showing up when I don't want it to be part of the experience. Instead I rely upon the "Highlights" and "Show all" in Google Photo's to manage my presentations with or without the 2nd back side images. Weirdly I have to use Google Picasa to sort them the way I want them. Google drive itself is fubaring its thumbnail images soon with an update to default drive viewer experience that reduces the footprint(CROP) of the thumbnail somewhat similar to what Evernote does in cropping its "randomly" chosen thumbnail. The write answer is to shrink the users selected image to fit the predefined thumbnail size. Both Evernote and Google appear to be thwarting the ideal use of images for those who store artwork on their cloud depositories. Mainly I use evernote to tag my images for managing my collection rather than view it in Evernote due to these issues. 

Evernote, if you take presentation so seriously as to provide Premium with presentation mode then please for the love of the cosmos give us thumbnail control.

[Frank.dg 1,385]

How about Evernote's new Mac feature – that of being able to resize images inline… Could that affect the largest smallest dimension in any way?

[Jens Schriver 2]

It's getting increasingly frustrating that this is not an option. I use images extensively for art projects and the thumbnails are the quickest way to visually identify notes - however, as reference photos are added the thumbnail changes and identification becomes confusing.

 

Definitely a +1 from me!

[AdrianBrancato 6]

"Thumbnail override option" is definitely a LONG OVERDUE request.  

I am amazed (and frustrated) that apparently EN hasn't done a thing to address this obvious oversight.

 

[Frank.dg 1,385]

"Thumbnail override option" is definitely a LONG OVERDUE request.  

I am amazed (and frustrated) that apparently EN hasn't done a thing to address this obvious oversight.

 

I'm curious... perhaps Mac users on the forum could report back on whether the largest-smallest dimension can in any way be affected when one re-sizes  images inline. If so, would that not resolve this situation when the common editor rolls out to all platforms (if inline-image re-sizing is in fact part of the standardization)?

[AdrianBrancato 6]

I am a Mac user, latest OS X and latest Evernote.  I tried just that: resizing images inline in the note.  No amount of resizing seemed to have any effect on the selection of thumbnail image.

[KevinRC5 2]

I'm adding my two cents to this one, too.  I would LOVE to be able to choose the thumbnail.  As it stands, Evernote almost never chooses the thumbnail I would choose.  Which means the thumbnails are a DISTRACTION to finding the note I want, not a HELP.

 

If I could choose the thumbnail, when needed, it would be a HUGE HELP.

 

This exactly is what kept me from committing to Evernote as a premium subscriber.  The thumbnail selection is a distraction that can make it HARDER --not easier-- to find what I want.

 

This particular discussion has been going on for 3 years, so how has it not been a priority to come up with a way to override the automatic thumbnail selection with manual choice of thumbnail image that would actually let us associate images that we know will work for us with our notes?  Overall, Evernote is a great application, so I can't imagine incompetence is the reason... so I can only guess that its a continued, willful choice to force the built in algorithm to choose for us.

 

VERY amateurish effort in that regard, guys.  Please try to fix this. 

[mptpro 2]

Why not 1) select the first image in a note as the thumbnail

2) also let the user override this by selecting a specific image as the thumbnail?

[icebox 0]

+1 For letting allowing us to change the thumbnail.

 

Second issue, has the algorithm changed ? I was scrapping some webpages and I always get a thumbnail of the "unknown" face of the avatars instead of pictures from the article. I'm using the beta clipper for Firefox. Here is an example site where this happends: http://www.mash4077tv.com/2014/12/08/episode-spotlight-mail-call-again/

 

I even tried removing all avatar images from the note but the thumbnail remains.

[Natalie 9]

I'm a Mac user as well. I've tried too, doesn't seem to work for me either. 

 

Any word from Evernote on whether they are working on this? I'm debating finding another program to use as this is becoming too frustrating to deal with. 

[AntonioXeira 1]

Its a must. I keep coming back looking for this.

[KevinRC5 2]

+1 For letting allowing us to change the thumbnail.

 

Second issue, has the algorithm changed ? I was scrapping some webpages and I always get a thumbnail of the "unknown" face of the avatars instead of pictures from the article. I'm using the beta clipper for Firefox. Here is an example site where this happends: http://www.mash4077tv.com/2014/12/08/episode-spotlight-mail-call-again/

 

I even tried removing all avatar images from the note but the thumbnail remains.

Just one more reason why a manual override selection should be possible.

[Scott-W 9]

It's been 3.5 years since this problem was identified.  No action from Evernote.

 

I'm willing to sign any formal petitions.

 

I'm open to alternative applications.

[DrunkenCyclist 21]

WOW!!!!

I decided to try Evernote after having abandoned the idea several years ago.

Within 15 minutes of starting to use it I began to wonder how I can change the thumbnail image represented on notes -- because web clippings are pulling in BANNER ADS to append to the note thumbnails.

Then I started reading all these threads about how people have been requesting this feature for several years and being ignored.

I'm done with Evernote now for good -- after a single hour of playing around with it.

 

Just thought I'd throw that in there. It typically doesn't take me long to reject apps based on completely stupid UI decisions -- and this is just another example.

I'm beyond shocked that the whole point of Evernote is to organize your notes -- and it doesn't even let you choose a thumbnail image???

I am a UI developer who maintains a very large web app. One of the features of this app is the ability to scrape content such as articles from sites and pull it into our system. We give our users a left / right arrow to CHOOSE which image represents their content instead of doing all this hogwash to have a ROBOT try and figure out what the user wants.

How about just let the USER choose what the USER wants to do? It is much simpler from a development standpoint AND makes the users happy too. We even let them CROP the damn images before they are imported into our system. I mean, this is standard fare, considering that's also how FACEBOOK works.

How the imbiciles who threw this app together can't figure THAT out just shows me this app will get on my nerves even more if I tried to use it for a week.

[DrunkenCyclist 21]

Well, after looking at explanation of how the "largest smallest" dimensions determine which image becomes the thumbnail, it makes more sense from a development standpoint as that is a simpler approach than letting the user choose their image -- but from a usability standpoint -- who really wants to see a bunch of banner ads attached to their notes in the list views -- images that have nothing to do whatsoever with the content of the note?

I am still shocked that nobody has addressed this with users for the last 3 years people seem to have been asking for it.

[AdrianBrancato 6]

Whoa!  That was quite a leap, from irritation to outright rejection!  ;-)

 

I have accumulated nearly 9,000 notes, from 1997 when I started collecting digital notes on my Palm PDA.  Through those years I have been forced to use some pretty sorry software from major vendors.  Then I "went over to the white side".  I've used EN since 2011 and I've seen no reason to switch.  It has handled the heavy volume of data without a hiccup.

[DrunkenCyclist 21]

LOL -- I guess I am passionate about good UI experiences. I am going to give it an honest try because I think the benefits outweigh the things that "irritate" me before I slam the door shut. There is no such thing as a perfect system that makes EVERYONE happy in every way, and developer should make that his/her goal either.

 

I'm a visual person and can agree with people in here who say being able to choose which image they'd like for the note will help them spot it in a list view (which is the whole point of having one).

It would not be hard, since they already scrape the content to find all the images in the first place -- to create an easy way for a user to simply choose which one to use, or disable it.

I know the goal of the "everything bucket" concept of having a place for "digital hoarders" to keep their stuff somewhat organized isn't to make eveything "pretty" -- but I think there's a wider benefit than being able to choose "eye candy" for your notes here.

[AdrianBrancato 6]

Oh, I agree completely.  This seemingly simple feature has been overlooked for too long.

 

Digital Hoarder?  Did you really say, "Digital Hoarder"??    Guilty as charged!   LOL 

 

Another peeve of mine is EN's inability to accept punctuation marks as valid characters in a search string, but that should be a different post.

[DrunkenCyclist 21]

Yeah, the danger I see with this already is that while the desktops of several computers I use shall be clean, and my google drive less messy -- I'll end up with a digital closet that looks like an episode of "Hoaders" with this.

I ran into one glitch with copy / pasting some notes from a plain text file into an ever-note already but then on the plus side, I can already think of one scenario that would have been useful to me recently in regards to having quick access to some PDF files I typically need to find on their source web site(s) whenever I need to reference them, so I can see this being useful. I already keep most of my "notes" for things in a google drive, but this seems to be a step up from that.

 

I read a couple of lifehacker articles about things people are doing with EN that were a little bit outside of the box and it inspired me to give it another shot. I tried it a few years back and just couldn't get into it.

[AdrianBrancato 6]

I didn't take to it at first either, but on import EN swallowed my entire 8K note hoard quickly and smoothly.  Some others I tried, like SimpleNote, literally choked part way through.  Apple's Notes accepted all of my data but then the web interface would crash each time I tried to do a search.  EN is tough, and from what I've seen very careful with my precious data.