-tim

Despite what I thought fixed it, the observation made by ArneG might have applied to me in fact. I have an unused (forgotten) Evernote account associated with one email address, and a used Evernote account associated with my gmail address. Although I don't log in through my google account (gmail address but Evernote password), perhaps something I did with that fixed the issue for me.

@obromios I was having the same problem a couple of days ago, and fixed it by using the free AppCleaner application to uninstall Evernote, and then reinstalled it. Just deleting Evernote from the Applications folder wasn't enough. FYI I got the Evernote installer from their site. I hope this works for you!