I gave up for a while. It's a year later now, and Paste to Evernote is not working. Even while Evernote is Open. Even while I'm immediately within the active Evernote window. Changing the shortcut has not made a difference. I have various other apps, clipboard manager, etc. and things and those and their shortcuts all work fine. (Disabling any of those has no apparent impact on any other app, Evernote included. Anyway, there should be no interference.) The only way I'm able to get things into Evernote now is to open Evernote, create a new note, and paste content there. I've used Evernote a LOT less as a result. And I'm sad about the whole thing. Also, for a paid app, the lack of access to service is disturbing.