@PinkElephant - I am not sure what your association with Evernote is. I assume that you are not an employee of Evernote and say that you dont care about a customer leaving. Clearly, you dont seem to know the product well. This was the default option for multiple versions of Evernote until some genious product manager decided to change this.
if you are changing to body of text atleast do an attempt to fill the title with first line of body. if someone forgets, it will have untitled as the title. Very brilliant design.