Jump to content
  • 249
marcelo

Control Which Image Shown in a Note's Thumbnail/Snippet View

Idea

I do like the new layout with larger thumbnails, except for one thing: Evernote seems to choose as thumbnail the largest image within a note. But it is rather annoying, for it seldom coincides with the image which would enable me to recognize a note at once. Can I somehow force Evernote to use a specific image as thumbail?

Marcelo

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post

Recommended Posts

  • 0
No.

Thank you for your prompt reply. Does it mean the only way to force an image to appear as thumbnail is to make sure that it is the heaviest one within the note?

Thanks

Marcelo

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
Thank you for your prompt reply. Does it mean the only way to force an image to appear as thumbnail is to make sure that it is the heaviest one within the note?

You're welcome. I don't know how EN selects the thumbnail.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
I don't know how EN selects the thumbnail.

We select the image with the largest smallest dimension. There are some other rules, but that's the main one.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

We select the image with the largest smallest dimension. There are some other rules, but that's the main one.

The largest smallest dimension?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
The largest smallest dimension?

:)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
The largest smallest dimension?

Yeah. For example, if you have 3 images with the following dimensions:

75x100

100x400

200x300

The "smallest" dimensions are 75, 100, and 200, respectively. We're going to use the image with the largest of those "smallest" dimensions (i.e., 200).

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

OK, got it. I think anything else would have too many words, and "largest smallest" probably works because it's short and easy to remember (and apparently self-contradictory). Cool.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Yeah. For example, if you have 3 images with the following dimensions:

75x100

100x400

200x300

The "smallest" dimensions are 75, 100, and 200, respectively. We're going to use the image with the largest of those "smallest" dimensions (i.e., 200).

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

Thanks for the explanation. I guess if someone really wanted to promote a specific image, they could use a photo editor to re-size the photos. That's too much work for me.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
The largest smallest dimension?

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

You learn something every day. :)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Yeah. For example, if you have 3 images with the following dimensions:

75x100

100x400

200x300

The "smallest" dimensions are 75, 100, and 200, respectively. We're going to use the image with the largest of those "smallest" dimensions (i.e., 200).

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

One way to express this in a more definitive way is the image with the largest width, assuming that your example you gave is in the order of width x height.

However, it is not clear that this is actually what you mean.

For example, what if we add an image that is 250x150?

Then the list would be:

75x100

100x400

200x300

250x150

Does that mean that EN would now select the last image (250x150) for the thumbnail?

Well, I'm going out of the business of making suggestions, but as one of the last, does it make sense to anyone at Evernote to choose the first image in the Note for the thumbnail?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

An alternative is the image with the largest number of pixels. This is a good predictor of importance of the image to the note's content.

e.g.

75x100=7500

100x400=40000

200x300=60000

250x150=37500

Largest -> 200x300=60000

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

One way to express this in a more definitive way is the image with the largest width, assuming that your example you gave is in the order of width x height.

My list is ordered by increasing size of smallest dimension. We don't want to pick the image with the largest width, since that would result in us selecting things like graphical horizontal lines (e.g., 600x1) for some notes, which isn't very useful.

For example, what if we add an image that is 250x150?

Then the list would be:

75x100

100x400

200x300

250x150

Does that mean that EN would now select the last image (250x150) for the thumbnail?

No, we choose the image with the largest smallest dimension. To keep my list sorted by increasing size of smallest dimension, your new entry should be third:

75x100

100x400

150x250

200x300

So we're going to pick the last one again (200x300), because it's still the image with the "largest smallest" dimension.

does it make sense to anyone at Evernote to choose the first image in the Note for the thumbnail?

It does make sense sometimes, but it doesn't make sense a significant number of times too. Some part of the algorithm needs to factor in the dimensions and/or sizes of the images or else you end up with non-useful thumbnails (see 600x1 example above).

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
An alternative is the image with the largest number of pixels. This is a good predictor of importance of the image to the note's content.

e.g.

75x100=7500

100x400=40000

200x300=60000

250x150=37500

Largest -> 200x300=60000

Yeah, that's probably another good algorithm (and note that in this specific case, that is the image we choose). I think we're reasonably happy with the algorithm we're using; they're all subject to false positives, unfortunately, but I think our algorithm ends up choosing a fairly representative image a lot of the time.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Well, it does have the advantage of being easier to explain. Which usually results in a more likely to be correct implementation.

The best, and most likely, implementation of either algorithm would pick the first "largest" in the event of a tie.

My guess is that in most cases (>90%) either algorithm would pick the same image for the thumbnail.

Hmmm.

Not sure which algorithm is more likely to pick the squarer image. Squarer usually results in a more recognizable thumbnail. Probably a toss up.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
Well, it does have the advantage of being easier to explain. Which usually results in a more likely to be correct implementation.

Hmmm, bubble sort is easy to explain, and it's not hard to get a correct implementation of a bubble sort, but so what? Implementation is not usually the problem, it's choice of algorithm, and bubble sort is of course notoriously poor for anything but the most trivial uses.

The best, and most likely, implementation of either algorithm would pick the first "largest" in the event of a tie.

My guess is that in most cases (>90%) either algorithm would pick the same image for the thumbnail.

Hmmm.

Not sure which algorithm is more likely to pick the squarer image. Squarer usually results in a more recognizable thumbnail. Probably a toss up.

I think you're right -- there are probably fail cases in any algorithm that will be used to pick a thumbnail candidate out of a collection of images. I think that making a good guess is fine, but the best case for users would probably be to allow them to designate which image to use if the guess is not the one that they want.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
bubble sort
:lol:

Nah. This is a single pass scan. No sorting. Just compares.

And, bubble sort, can NOT be fully described in a single, non-compound, sentence.

----------

Ummm. Re-read your comment. Never mind my comment about single pass. You were using it as an general example, not a specific example. :?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Right -- just trying to illustrate that things that are easy to describe may not be the best choice. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Sometimes I have multiple images in a post, and evernote seems to pretty randomly choose which one to use as a thumbnail. Is there any way to pick which one it is? Sometimes the photo chosen is no help at all, so I would like to be able to change it, either by selecting which one or being able to determine what position to put the one I want in (i.e. first or last) so it gets picked.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Can someone tell me why evernote doesn't have this ability yet? This seems incredibly near-sighted.

I read on someone else's post that evernote uses an algorithm to choose the thumbnail image depending on what the largest image is, it uses that one as the thumbnail.

I want the algorithm to conform to ME, not the other way around.

:)

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I don't know why but I'm sure it's much easier to have a standard system on the servers that does this rather than implement this feature across all the platforms EN lives on. You don't have to like it, but that's the way it is. (shrug)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

But it doesn't seem like that because I can go in and edit my notes to my heart's content. So if I can edit my notes as much as I'd like, I feel like that would be even more difficult to accompany than the ability to change the note's thumbnail. It seems silly that I can have all of this customization to my note, but NOT the thumbnail image. It would be much easier to have a standard system on the servers that doesn't let you edit your note at all. Less coding to be flexible with the whims of its users.

So since this is NOT the case, it seems strange that the ability to edit the thumbnail of the note is not available, while I can edit my note to any degree I wish (something arguably more complex to account for than changing a thumbnail).

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

How do you assign a specific thumbnail to a note?

I have many images in many notes. When there is more than one image, EN does not always take the topmost (first) image as the note's thumbnail image. In addition, even if you "trick" EN to use a given image as the thumbnail by creating the note with only one image initially then adding others after the thumbnail has been generated, EN will sometimes reassign the thumbnail image to one of the subsequent images within the note.

This is frustrating when these thumbnails are instrumental in quickly identifying notes, but there seems to be no predictable way to control them.

Perhaps this should be a field in the note header area where you "Click to set thumbnail image" would work.

Any advice would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Steve & Angela

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Here is a link to a discussion on this issue. There is no easy solution if you have several photos in one note. I guess if someone really wanted to promote a specific image, they could use a photo editor to re-size the photo to create the "largest smallest dimension".

That's too much work for me.

http://discussion.ev...dpost__p__92194

Evernote explanation:

We select the image with the largest smallest dimension. There are some other rules, but that's the main one.

Examples:

75x100

100x400

200x300

The "smallest" dimensions are 75, 100, and 200, respectively. We're going to use the image with the largest of those "smallest" dimensions (i.e., 200).

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
The largest smallest dimension?

Yeah. For example, if you have 3 images with the following dimensions:

75x100

100x400

200x300

The "smallest" dimensions are 75, 100, and 200, respectively. We're going to use the image with the largest of those "smallest" dimensions (i.e., 200).

There are probably better ways to describe that algorithm, but that's how we've been describing it internally.

with all due respect, what you really mean is the "largest smaller" dimension. :D

for the word "smallest" to apply, you'd have to be comparing at least 3 items -- or, in this case, dimensions (such as the 3 sides of a triangle, or 3 or more of anything, really). but images are two-dimensional; they have only height and width. therefore, neither dimension is the "smallest" of the two; it's the smaller of the two. :)

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

The way the system works now is completely non-intuitive. A larger image does not mean a better representation of what the note is about. I could make a strong argument that the first image in the note (above a certain size threshold) would be the most representative of the note. For example, I took a clipping of a product page. I want to capture the primary product but also the "related products". However, the images of the related products happen to be larger than the primary product so now I have a note about one product with images for a different one shown as the thumbnail. I have similar frustration for other scenarios as well. I agree, the image for the thumbnail on the note should be user-selectable. It's fine to have a default, but I should be able to override it if I wish. Right-click the image --> Set as thumbnail. Simple. Even if that is a desktop-only feature, that's fine. The product already has certain features that only exist in certain implementations of the product, so that's nothing new.

  • Like 6

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

@Gimpster: Please read the discussions jbenson2 posted, it is *not* the largest image that is used. On the other hand, overriding the system-selected image used would be a nice improvement. It's not clear to me that that's something that is transferred with the note; it may be determined on-the-fly by the client (I haven't been able to figure it out by looking at an exported .ENEX file yet), though I suppose it's also possible that that's determined by a call to the server, too.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I wasn't searching to find out whether or not changing the thumbnail was possible, I was searching to find out how to go about changing the thumbnail. I guess that's what you get when you make assumptions! :)

I hope this will be implemented at some point soon. As Gimpster pointed out, a desktop-only option would be fine (similar to changing the added and modified dates).

As it stands now, your notes can really end up with some odd and completely illogical thumbnails!

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
As it stands now, your notes can really end up with some odd and completely illogical thumbnails!

Most of my thumbnails are so illogical that I pretty much just ignore them in the Snippet view.

It would be very cool to right-click on the Snippet View Note, and select "Choose Thumbnail".

EN could present a selection of images in thumbnail size for the user to pick from.

It would seem that EN has all of the data it needs to do this in a small popup window, since the Note images are all files which EN knows for each Note.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

One of the ways I use Evernote is to store photographs (JPEGs) with notes on how I've processed them and a copies of the picture as processed by the camera (JPEG) and the original file (RAW format) . So, typically there will be three images in the post, interspersed with text:

Edited JPEG

Camera JPEG

RAW file (this is not displayed in the note, as you need specialist software to interpret RAW files, so it is just a file attachment)

I like to have the edited photo first, so you can see it straight away and then scroll down to see my notes.

I also share some of these notes in a shared notebook with fellow hobbyists, so these comments also relate to the Web version of Evernote.

In Windows.

Evernote seems to choose the last JPEG you add to a note as the thumbnail and this is invariably the camera JPEG, which doesn't look as nice.

In Web.

Evernote doesn't display a thumbnail in the snippet at all, although it does if there are only JPEGs in the note. I think it wants to make a thumbnail of the last image added to the note but it can't because it's a RAW file.

I would prefer Evernote in all cases to use the first image in the note.

Can anyone think of any way of achieving this?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

AFAIK there's no way to choose which picture EN uses in snippet view where there's a choice of files. I don't think it regards RAW and as image file format though.

You could try to force your 1st picture to the head of the queue by zipping all the others, so there's only one choice; or maybe use apply two-note policy - put your headline picture in one note and add a link to another note with the rest of the details. If you're sharing these notes it would speed up page loading - the 'index' note could just be a small(er) thumbnail version of the main picture with the full detail in a linked Note.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

You could try to force your 1st picture to the head of the queue by zipping all the others, so there's only one choice; or maybe use apply two-note policy - put your headline picture in one note and add a link to another note with the rest of the details. If you're sharing these notes it would speed up page loading - the 'index' note could just be a small(er) thumbnail version of the main picture with the full detail in a linked Note.

Thanks gazumped. Those scenarious would solve the problem but inconvenience me in other ways! But I appreciate you taking the time to think about it.

gazumped is basically correct; Evernote chooses the thumbnail for the snippet. The procedure used, at least the last time that anyone from Evernote commented on it is something called the 'largest smallest dimension'; it's explained here: http://discussion.ev...gest%20smallest

Thanks for the link jefito. I see now, the problem is that all my images are the same size so it's either picking randomly or using some other rule (not sure why I get no image in snippets in the Web version though). I could resize the other images to make sure my preferred image is the one that appears as the thumbnail, but that too is a faff.

I think I'll just live with it as it is.

From the other topic I see it's been suggested before that users be able to select which image appears as a thumbnail and I think that would be good. I can imagine hovering over the thumbnail and seeing alternatives to click on.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I would really like to be able to choose the thumbnail. Is there a way to make and/or support suggestions for new Evernote features (like UserVoice)? Or will people just raise these topics in the forums and hope that they get the attention of Evernote developers?

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just post here and the community as well as EN developers will read it.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

So may I add my voice to this request.

Thanks to you guys for explaining the largest-smallest or whatever algorithm. I can see clearly now. However, I would love to choose which one of the pictures in a note is shown as preview thumbnail. Because the "largest-smaller or whatever" pic rarely is the one that indicates my note perfectly. ;)

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hello,

I am new to Evernote, I just started using it today and the first wall I hit was not being able to change the thumbnails on my notes. Then I came to this forum and read all this stuff about choosing the right algorithm for automatically generating a thumbnail.

What puzzles me is: How do you put that much thought into selecting an algorithm for auto-generating an image for a more intuitive note-taking experience... and not consider letting us pick our own?

For instance, I'm trying to use EN to compare-shop different audio interfaces for my macbook... a note for each model I'm considering... but the thumbnails are a mess; they show the store logos or ads that also appear on the page but none show the actual item I'm trying to compare. Is my intuition that far-fetched? This forum topic started a year ago, and it's still unchanged, really?

Is it me? If there's a different, more positive way for me to view this, please let me know.

Thanks

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

OK, got it. I think anything else would have too many words, and "largest smallest" probably works because it's short and easy to remember (and apparently self-contradictory). Cool.

...except it's somewhat ineptly named, because at least 3 items (in this case, "dimensions") are required for the suffix "-est" to be applicable. therefore, since an image has only 2 dimensions, 1 dimension would be the smaller of the two, not the smallest. so, it should be the "largest smaller" dimension. :)

but i don't think jeff coined the phrase, so it's not his fault. :)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

The fact that something is the smaller of two items doesn't make it any less the smallest.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

The fact that something is the smaller of two items doesn't make it any less the smallest.

with all due respect, you just don't get it. if you understood grammar, you'd realize your statement was nonsensical. :)

you can't just decide to use the wrong word because it "sounds right" to you. though you may think the two words are interchangeable, they simply are not. the smaller of two items is NOT the smallest. it's the smaller. the word "smallest" is grammatically incorrect. period. if you use the word "smallest," the fact that someone will understand what you "mean" doesn't change the fact that it's grammatically (and mathematically) incorrect.

unless there are at least three items being compared, "-est" is ineligible for use. there are no exceptions. :)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

You may be on somewhat better ground grammatically speaking, but with "all due respect", you have no idea what you are talking about, mathematically speaking. Maybe you should "put your best foot forward" and try to learn something. You do have more than two feet, do you not?

Because despite what you claim, it is mathematically correct: "smallest" refers to the smallest member of a set, regardless of how many elements are in the set (even if there's only one). When we apply the function "smallest" to a set, it doesn't return failure if the set has at least one element, it just returns the smallest element. In computer programming, I don't need to write a special function that operates only on sets of two items, I write one function that works for all.

unless there are at least three items being compared, "-est" is ineligible for use. there are no exceptions. :)

Except for the exception when the number is indeterminate from context. *cough, cough*

So maybe yes, you are technically correct with respect to grammar, but language is used for communication, and if someone understands what I say, then language's work is accomplished. So feel free to pick your prescriptive nits if that's how you want to spend your time here but everyone here (including you) understands the phrase "smallest dimension", even when it's applied to a two dimensional object. Language and the human mind are both flexible enough to manage.

By the way, I've noticed a lot of misspellings and misplaced commas elsewhere in the forums, and I think there's a run on split infinitives going on in the Android forum; are you up for it?

p.s., following an insult with a smiley doesn't make it less insulting, it makes it passive aggressive. You might want to watch that.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

You may be on somewhat better ground grammatically speaking, but with "all due respect", you have no idea what you are talking about, mathematically speaking. Maybe you should "put your best foot forward" and try to learn something. You do have more than two feet, do you not?

math was one of my college majors. i began my college mathematics courses at the age of 15, and i ultimately graduated summa cum laude (valedictorian) with a 3.98 GPA.

it was one of our math professors who taught us that "the language of mathematics is exact, concise, and precise." if you're comparing only two objects (or concepts), the word "smallest" simply cannot, and does not, apply. the fact that you believe with all your heart that it does does not change that. that's all i have to say on the matter.

p.s., following an insult with a smiley doesn't make it less insulting, it makes it passive aggressive. You might want to watch that.

i didn't write "insults," per se; i simply stated facts. but, aware that they might bristle, i added smileys to indicate friendly disagreement. i'm sorry you didn't appreciate that approach. with that in mind, in the purest sense -- meaning "possessing a lack of knowledge on a subject," as opposed to lacking intelligence -- i'll just say: you're ignorant. (no smiley. better?)

we're at an impasse... there's nothing more i can add, and nothing you can say that will change the facts. at this point, you'll be tempted to digress into pure insults, and i'm not going to participate in that. so, i will read/post no further, and i wish you the best of luck. (again, no smiley. i hope that's to your liking.)

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

First: if by saying "I'm sorry", however you're apologizing for your part in that misunderstanding, then I sincerely return the apology, for my part in it.

That said, math was one of my majors as well. I am certainly not ignorant on that score. It's been 30+ years since graduation, but my in my field -- computer software -- I still use math a pretty fair amount (that would be an understatement). Curiously, as it happens, I also took a college math course and a computer programming course at the age of 15, but that was just a one-off thing; I'm not trying to start a "who's got the biggest, um, brain" contest here.

But are you really, really saying that there can be no smallest element of a set containing two objects? If so, you are sadly mistaken. The term "smaller", in math and in general speech, mind, is a specialization of the more general concept of "smallest", but which is only used to apply to sets of two things. That doesn't malke "smallest" stop working on sets containing two (or even one) objects; it's just a convention that we have that we use "smaller" to apply to sets containing two objects. For sets with cardinality equal to 2, "smaller" is equivalent to "smallest". For sets of other cardinality, "smaller" doesn't apply.

Mathematically we might say something like: smallest is a function mapping a set of numbers A to the number x in A, such that for all members y of A, x <= y. This works for all sets of any cardinality, except of course, the empty set, which has no members. There's nothing wrong with calling out smaller as a specialization of smallest; mathematicians apply special names to common or useful subsets all the time, but that's all it is: a specialization of a more general rule. The smallest function doesn't magically stop working when it encounters a set of two elements, it just returns the smaller of the two.

[by the way: your professor's saying ("the language of mathematics is exact, concise, and precise") is cute, but not exactly mathematical by his own definition, as "precise" and "exact" are synonyms, and so therefore not "concise". Maybe it was just wishful thinking?]

And the linguistic rule whereby we apply to "smaller" to pairs of items, and "smallest" to sets of items with 3 or more members and sets with indeterminate size, that's just a convention, just like the rule whereby we ought not seek to blithely split infinitives, or start a sentence with "and", or the kazillion other conventions that operate in some realms of the English language (but certainly not all of them). You might prefer to call these conventions "facts", but they're not exactly enduring ones. So long as meaning is conveyed without confusion, and I'm pretty certain that you are not confused by the use of "smallest" when applied to two dimensions. Miffed, piqued, or annoyed, perhaps, but that's just a matter probably best kept between you and your favorite grammar book.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Apologies for the necropost, but I would like to throw in a vote for some way to override what thumbnail I use for a note. This would be helpful in journals where you want to add an image to a note, but you also use a different set of images to put at the end so you associate that day with that thumbnail image. Perhaps a right click on images that says "Make this the note thumbnail in X view?"

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I'd also like to add a vote for a way to manually say "make this image the thumbnail". (A right click on the image option would be really nice.)

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hey guys,

I had the same problem today and ran into this post.

I know for some going around chaning sizes is a bit tedious, however here is something that worked for me:

System Description:

Windows 7 Professional

Evernote version 4.5.6

1) Once all your images are loaded on the note right click on those you want to resize.

2) The image will automatically be selected and a pop up menu will appear.

3) Select "open with" option and then choose Paint

4) The file will open in Paint and windows will read it as a temp file from memory.

5) Choose resize and resize the picture to a smaller size, let's say 50%.

6) You can then click save and windows will automatically save the file in Evernote automatically resizing the image on the note itself.

It seems Windows has the ability to recognise the file loaded from Evernote and resize it on the fly.

It is not an automated solutions an I know is not as good as what we would all want which is right click --> set as thumbnail.

But it works pretty well and it saves a lot of time of mucking around with a picture file and try to resize it before loading it into the note.

I hope this works for those that want a better way.

Cheers,

=)

./h

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I'd also love to have a feature, which lets me pick my own thumbnail.

The current algorithm is -lets name it- random. For me as user it makes absolutely no sense to use this algorithm.

In each of my notes I have multiple images with more or less importance. And the thumbnail should be the most important or meaningful image. Not the one with the best proportions!

Please, please include this feature!!!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just as a matter of interest? what was the thinking behind this rule to select the thumbnail LOL.... why not just go with the first or last image/attachment in the note?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just as a matter of interest? what was the thinking behind this rule to select the thumbnail LOL.... why not just go with the first or last image/attachment in the note?

I think this is a case of the programmers trying to be cool with a "clever" algorithm, yet they did not have a good understanding of the end-user's needs/perspective. We have tried several times to convince the EN team that the current selection process does not work very well, but they don't seem to want to hear it.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just as a matter of interest? what was the thinking behind this rule to select the thumbnail LOL.... why not just go with the first or last image/attachment in the note?

I think this is a case of the programmers trying to be cool with a "clever" algorithm, yet they did not have a good understanding of the end-user's needs/perspective. We have tried several times to convince the EN team that the current selection process does not work very well, but they don't seem to want to hear it.

I don't think your speculation about the developers is supported by the evidence. In fact, they seem very concerned about the user experience :)

What I got out of the developer comments in this thread is that they were looking for a way to populate the thumbnails with images that would make sense to the user and avoid having horizontal bars or other non-sensical images showing up. The process occurs automatically and actually does a good job in most cases for me. As we discussed in the other thread, there are good things about the product, but also areas that need improvement.

It seems like a smart design decision, and I like it, but I think it would be nice if users had the option to overide the algorithm in a note. Hopefully, the developers will consider this in future updates.

Just because the developers don't do what we ask them to do doesn't mean they are not listening or not hearing us. We may have been un-persuasive. They might be waiting to roll it out together with a different update so that they don't have to recode for a new interface. They might disagree. Or, they could be too busy. Who knows? Rather than questioning their commitment to a good user experience, I think we can offer real life use cases that will help them design it better in future ones.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

It seems like a smart design decision, and I like it, but I think it would be nice if users had the option to overide the algorithm in a note. Hopefully, the developers will consider this in future updates.

I disagree. It may be "smart" from a technical point of view, but not of a users point of view.

There is very little correlation between the image size and what image is the most important, or most relevant, to the user.

On top of that, the thumbnail often crops the image in the middle, making it almost unrecognizable.

Don't see anything "smart" about this.

Choosing the first image whose width and height are both greater than that used for borders would be "smart", as well a give the user control over which image is used for the thumbnail.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

It sounds crazy on the face of it..... But they will have tried different settings and could immediately see the effect on thumbnails.... The problem is everybody's notebooks are different so what might work well for the majority may be rubbish for 40% of users.....

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

It seems like a smart design decision, and I like it, but I think it would be nice if users had the option to overide the algorithm in a note. Hopefully, the developers will consider this in future updates.

I disagree. It may be "smart" from a technical point of view, but not of a users point of view.

There is very little correlation between the image size and what image is the most important, or most relevant, to the user.

On top of that, the thumbnail often crops the image in the middle, making it almost unrecognizable.

Don't see anything "smart" about this.

Choosing the first image whose width and height are both greater than that used for borders would be "smart", as well a give the user control over which image is used for the thumbnail.

It works pretty well from this user's point of view. The images chosen are appropriate, and even when cut-off (as they must be to fit within the constraints of the snippet view), they are perfectly recognizable.The designers must have done something right if the results work so well a lot of the time (for this user, at least), so I'll stick with calling the current implementation "smart." It would be "smarter," of course, if they added the ability to override the existing algorithm :)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

It seems like a smart design decision, and I like it, but I think it would be nice if users had the option to overide the algorithm in a note. Hopefully, the developers will consider this in future updates.

I disagree. It may be "smart" from a technical point of view, but not of a users point of view.

There is very little correlation between the image size and what image is the most important, or most relevant, to the user.

On top of that, the thumbnail often crops the image in the middle, making it almost unrecognizable.

Don't see anything "smart" about this.

Choosing the first image whose width and height are both greater than that used for borders would be "smart", as well a give the user control over which image is used for the thumbnail.

It works pretty well from this user's point of view. The images chosen are appropriate, and even when cut-off (as they must be to fit within the constraints of the snippet view), they are perfectly recognizable.The designers must have done something right if the results work so well a lot of the time (for this user, at least), so I'll stick with calling the current implementation "smart." It would be "smarter," of course, if they added the ability to override the existing algorithm :)

Additionally, most people who have created/designed apps have made choices that seemed good at the time & later realize it may not have been. Reversing such choices may not always be an easy task. I have no idea whether EN has had any second thoughts on this choice. Nor do I care, b/c personally, I have no issue with the thumbnails. But I do think it's a waste of time to rag on the devs for choices they have made & applying each individual user's idea of what is easy/smart to something they really have no clue about, which is why the decision was made & why/how it affects all the platforms EN lives on.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Agreed, If they did change, it would need to stay as is for all the previous notes uploaded (as no doubt some people love it!) But you could have an option to go back to an old note and select another preference as well as overide when creating new ones.

So I think we've done this to death now... so I'm out B)

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

In my experience (on a Windows system), if I delete the picture that is selected as thumbnail, EverNote then pics the next picture as thumbnail. So I go through this process (delete, save note, undo) successively until it picks the picture I want. Tedious, but usually works.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I have read some posts regarding how Evernote 'decides' to select the thumbnail image to show on notes and I still do not understand why I cannot override this behavior by clicking on an image in a note and selecting "Assign Thumbnail". Until this is done I cannot pay money for Evernote as Springpad managed to get this working.

Even with this automatic method, Evernote PC vs Web vs Android do different things. On the PC I somehow managed to get the thumbnails that I wanted showing by cut/sync/pasting until it worked (highly annoying). Then I go to view my notes on the Web or Android client and the thumbnails are completely different (super annoying).

The most frustrating thing about the poor automatic selection is that even though I have say a 400x400 image that I wish to use as a thumbnail, it keeps picking PDF files that are also inside the not as the thumbnail. And RARELY is the first page of a PDF something I want as a thumbnail.

So *please* add a user assignable thumbnail option! I know better than you what I want to see as the thumbnail.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Return of The Zombie Thread

Quick question...

Thanks for the algorithm, but I have one request...

Why not at the very least provide an override feature?

That cant be to hard. Assuming that because an image has specific dimensions it is thus more important is great for auto selecting an image. Why not provide a Right-Click Option such as "Choose Tumbnail."

I'm working on a pattern library and a feature like this would be great, especially considering the fact that "In Action" or "Examples of Use" images/Screenshots are much larger than the typical dimensions of lets say a Combo Box, Text Input Field, Drop Down Menu, etc....

A "Choose Thumbnail" option would be AMAZING!

See attached file for example..

post-105814-0-75117800-1348864416_thumb.

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I would also like the ability to choose the thumbnail for a note. As an example, I have photographed several recipes; one picture of the actual dish and one picture of the accompanying text (recipe). In most cases the thumbnail chosen is the 'wrong' one. I would like the thumbnail to be the picture of the dish itself not the recipe text.

I've also spotted what appears to be a bug. I have EN running on my Android phone and Windows 7. In one case the thumbnail on the PC is 'correct' (i.e. a picture of the dish) but it still shows a text thumbnail on my phone, despite syncing.

Please, please, please add the ability to choose the thumbnail.

Regards

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I too would also like the ability to choose the specific thumbnail for a note, or make it always use the first image in a multiple image note.

My use case is using a notebook for my wine cellar. I like to take a photo of the front of the bottle and another image as the back of the bottle. I'd like to be able to set the image of the front of the bottle as my thumbnail.

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

+1 for an override option. The current selection algorithm might be sufficient for many users, but its unpredictability makes the card view much less consistent and useful than it could be, especially when you actually need fine control over how your data is displayed.

When attaching similarly or equally sized images, the thumbnail selection appears to be random and at times unexpectedly changes when tags are added, titles or note data changed etc., further causing frustration.

Some additional issues I have encountered:

A note containing both PDFs and attachments (such as a .pages document) does not display the PDF as thumbnail (as expected), but the icon of the attached file:

post-115310-0-36712400-1355155389_thumb.

Even when the source image resolution seems sufficient, thumbnails often appear letterboxed:

post-115310-0-18452600-1355155393_thumb.

All of these issues add to the feeling of the card view feeling very clunky and almost buggy at the moment.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

whenever i come across this problem, i sign in using the web interface.

in web evernote, whichever image you upload first to the note will be the thumbnail assigned to the note. not the most convenient workaround but beats understanding the whole "largest smallest" algorithm and editing the photos for that. in fact, i didn't know one is expected to do all that just to assign a thumbnail to a note until today!

support a feature to pick our own thumbnail like the others. can't imagine that's more complicated than the existing algorithm?!

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Evernote you are awesome.... :wub:

But lets stop the talk about algorithm.... I don't care....But something I do care about, is the custom thumbnails.

Looking forward to this feature second quarter 2013. :ph34r:

hey 2vet ! thank you for the tip !!! :D

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I FULLY Agree, this should definitely be something we can choose from ourselves. WE know what we want as our thumbnail image and no algorithim in the world will ever beat that.

 

Seems like a pretty darn easy feature to program into Evernote.  Just right click and choose "Set as Thumbnail" if the one the algorithm isn't what you want.

 

 

Thank you in advance for adding this to the next release guys :-)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Thank you in advance for adding this to the next release guys :-)

Seeing as how this is something that's been asked for for at least a couple of years (Forum search is handy), you may need to wait a few more releases...

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

All is in the title  :)

It will be great to choose wich image in a note could be display in the thumbnail. Actually after grab an internet page with the webclipper, Sometimes it's the first image, sometime not...

Best,

JC ( sorry for bad english ... I'm a froggy frenchy )

 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

All is in the title  :)

It will be great to choose wich image in a note could be display in the thumbnail. Actually after grab an internet page with the webclipper, Sometimes it's the first image, sometime not...

Best,

JC ( sorry for bad english ... I'm a froggy frenchy )

 

 

Hi. Welcome to the forums! I have merged your thread with this one on the same topic. 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I'm also TOTALLY frustrated by this limitation. I use the note cards as a visual database for collections and also for home inventory, and half the time the thumbnail image is not representative.

 

WE NEED THE ABILITY TO CHOOSE THE THUMBNAIL!!!! OR AT LEAST AN OPTION TO USE THE TOPMOST PICTURE IN THE NOTE (that would be simple to implement, right?? A whole lot simpler logic that the current convoluted and useless algorithm...).

 

As other posters have said, it is fine if this capability is confined to the desktop version.

 

I cannot understand how this thread has been going on for literally YEARS with no action.

 

Sorry for "shouting" but this is an elementary feature that is NEEDED in order to make Evernote useful.

 

Why is it not being addressed? Can someone at Evernote give a coherent reason why?

 

THANKS FOR LISTENING!

 

[Moderator: merged post with existing topic on choosing thumbnail]

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Another vote for letting us choose our thumbnail, or simply make it the first one in a note that is above a certain minimum size. That is easy to implement on the developer side, yet gives the user control.

 

PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE!!

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I can't believe all the arguments over semantics and algorithms,  when the need is clear, there needs to be a way to choose the "featured image" Wordpress can do it, a 1001 other app(lications) so why not Evernote?.

 

As a second choice you can use whatever selection you like, but Evernote, take note, the ability to select an image (if so wished) is clearly what I and many (most?) of your customers want, surely on that basis you should simply find a way to service this customer requirement (and soon) because giving your customers what they want is what your supposed to do?

 

No doubt someone will dispute my logic?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Absolutely agree.  The current situation is a complete complex mess.  A simple method of choosing which image is displayed as the overall thumbnail image for the note would be extremely useful.  I'm surprised such a useful update hasn't yet been implemented.   

 

I can't believe all the arguments over semantics and algorithms,  when the need is clear, there needs to be a way to choose the "featured image" Wordpress can do it, a 1001 other app(lications) so why not Evernote?.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hi,

 

I'm new to the forums so pardon me if I'm not going about it in the right way....

 

I've been trying out Evernote over the past couple of months and in general I love it but there is one thing I find very frustrating: there appears to be no way to control which part of an image is used as the thumbnail. The result is that the thumbnails are off centre or the main detail of the image is half cut off. The bottom line is that I think it makes the thumbnails look fairly unprofessional (which is a real pity because most of the rest of the Evernote interface looks great). 

 

I'm not really a FaceBook user but I seem to remember when creating a FaceBook profile the program allowed you to choose which part of a larger image you wanted to crop use as you main profile image. I wonder why Evernote has not built in something like this?

 

There is another forum thread entitled "Choosing a Thumbnail" from a year or so ago where another user called JMichael mentions this topic in passing stating: "the thumbnail often crops the image in the middle, making it almost unrecognizable" but no one else picks up on the point and the discussion goes on to other things.... anyway to me it is a pretty glaring flaw so I thought I'd make a new topic and see if others agreed with me....

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

"Why not provide a Right-Click Option such as "Choose Tumbnail."" Exactly guys! WTF! It cant be such a big deal.. 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

So.... 

 

It seems like I can select a photo.... crop the image.... select which part of the image to use as my icon / thumbnail / avatar on these Evernote user forums....

 

but I can't select and image, crop it, and select which part of it to use as a thumbnail when I'm actually using Evernote itself...?

 

I wonder what the thinking is behind implementing the feature for the forums but not for the actual program? Seems like a strange ordering of priorities....

 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

The forum is 3rd party software, 'rented' by Evernote and not written by them.

 

It's also pretty dreadful in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Yeah. I figured something like that. My second post was really just a bit of a lame attempt at some humour.

I didn't really want it to deflect attention from my main point: I think Evernote would look more professional if you had control over which part of an image is used as the thumbnail. It would look more professional and that would make it more useful in a professional setting.

That's all. 95% or 98% of Evernote is fantastic IMO.... it just has a couple of annoying little quirks that keeps it from being perfect at least for what I'd like to use it for.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Well offer to replace the largest smallest with the one you want, can be done within a note by right clicking. plus reset to default, functiinality like in address book picture select.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I have just created a whole bunch of notes that are made up of photos of the front and back of all the plastic cards in my wallet (trying for a thinner wallet). Most notes are just two photos, one being the front and the other the back of a card.

 

When I look at all the notes in my notebook I find that some notes are using the first photo (front of card) as the thumbnail and other notes are using the second photo (back of card) as the thumbnail. How do I fix  it so the notes always use the first photo as the thumbnail? This will make it easier when searching for a specific card.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I have just created a whole bunch of notes that are made up of photos of the front and back of all the plastic cards in my wallet (trying for a thinner wallet). Most notes are just two photos, one being the front and the other the back of a card.

 

When I look at all the notes in my notebook I find that some notes are using the first photo (front of card) as the thumbnail and other notes are using the second photo (back of card) as the thumbnail. How do I fix  it so the notes always use the first photo as the thumbnail? This will make it easier when searching for a specific card.

http://discussion.evernote.com/topic/18482-choosing-a-thumbnail/

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Thanks for super quick reply.

 

All I can say is "that's just weird". Would never have worked that one out. Glad I asked.

 

I have increased the size of the image I want as the thumbnail by a few pixels to force it to be the thumbnail.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

+1 for the option to select a primary/featured/thumbnail image. 

 

I'm sure much thought and research went into creating your algorithm, EverNote, and I appreciate that. It sounds like a wonderful way to select a default image when no other information about what's truly important to the user is present

 

But for a truly excellent user experience, allowing us to override the algorithm for individual notes by selecting the primary/featured/thumbnail image is crucial. 

 

An etic approach made sense before Evernote had a userbase; now that you have a substantial one, an emic approach is better suited. And the natives have spoken: being able to choose this image is important and will improve the experience.

 

I began using Evernote (quite recently) not only because I wanted a way to create visual notes (by adding images, drawings, etc), but because I wanted a way to visually scan my notes within notebooks to more easily find what I'm looking for and get a quick visual snapshot of the ideas/notes I have within notebooks. This puts great significance on the thumbnail image; often, however, the Evernote algorithm doesn't select the image I feel is most representative, making this tool less powerful and my experience more frustrating. 

 

Please consider adding an optional override now that you have this use user data to work with. 

 

Edited to add: If you are concerned about additional database resources being needed to make this change and the associated expense, why not make this a premium feature? 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

This worked fine on my Mac but it has had the opposite effect on my iPhone where all of the thumbnails now show the back of the cards, i.e. the second photo in the note.  :(

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I've spent much time right clicking and hunting options to be able to tweak thumbnail choices.... then a search found this thread.

Largest smallest is fine when the user had no input, but the user should be able to override. It's a case of 'IF user selects AND override exists, use override ELSE use current code ENDIF'

Please can we have this tweak added to the right click menu?

(Similarly, a notebook thumbnail image in notebook view would be lovely)

(Using Mac desktop - main. iOS. Windows desktop)

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I'm a Premium user and have been using Evernote for over a year and love it. I'm using it for a number of different uses and research projects. 

 

(1) However I wish I could choose the image that appears in the thumbnail for each note. You can't even fake it out because Evernote doesn't consistently choose the same image -- seems to choose one at random. If it always used the last image posted, then you could just make sure the one you wanted was the last image posted even if you had to cut the image and then repost it. It doesn't take the image at the top of the page either. The thumbnails are important to me as they give me a visual guide. 

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Nope - there's a zen concept called "the largest smallest dimension" which is gone into somewhere in the forums.  You can adjust the size of one picture so it will be the snippet.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I'm currently getting some notes that don't have ANY photo in the thumbnail (on iPad while looking at notes in a notebook) even though the very first item in the post is a picture...and there are multiple pictures in the note.

Any thoughts?

I *think* the items (recipes) in question were imported via an RSS reader but not sure why that would matter...?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

No real value in bumping one of your own threads (and it's not great forum etiquette).

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hi 

 

I completly agree - we should be able to choose the thumbnail image displayed for our notes - very frustrating - come on Evernote developers - sort this!

 

:angry: :angry: :angry: :angry:

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Look mate, what exactly is your problem...?

 

Every time I post something you turn up to slag off my idea or put me down personally.... why? What did I ever do to you?

 

You obviously seem to think you own the forum and no one is allowed to post unless they agree with you and "Burger-and-it-is-fine-if-I'm-rude-to-everyone-because-I-don't-get-paid-for-this".

 

Well good for you. Consider your "gatekeeping" a job well done, because I'll be -blanked- if I ever read or post on these forums again. Life is way to short to waste it talking to the likes of you.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

@<actus: Everyone is allowed to post, make suggestions, rant or praise or whatever, and it's very unlikely that you'd get censored in any way. But when you post, someone is liable to respond to you, and possibly disagree. Metrodon's last wasn't personal -- call it a reminder that it's really not necessary to bump your own posts (because when they get read by Evernote staff, "bumps" really don't add anything to the conversation); maybe you disagree, but was there some reason that you thought that bumping your own post was helpful to the forum? His point on the forum software vs. Evernote software was just informational; not sure whether you took that personally or not.

 

As for the original topic -- choice of thumbnail is something that's been requested elsewhere, as you know, and personally, I'd find it useful. Not sure that I'd need cropping but that's just me.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Thanks for posting <actus. I read this a while ago but didn't get a chance to respond. Either way, we'd love for you to stick around the forums.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

As a developer, I can attest that this would be an extremely easy feature to add. It could be done in three steps:

  1. Add to the images context menu the option to "Set as thumbnail".
  2. For the selected image, add an attribute like thumbnail="true" in the Evernote markup.
  3. When displaying a thumbnail, first scan for an image with this attribute. If one is not found, use the current algorithm.

I think the only real hurdle will be testing in all platforms.

 

Many of us have notes clipped from the web with the first or last image usually being the best one for the note. Much of what I clip are tutorials or instructables with photos for each step and most of the time the auto thumbnail is incorrect.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

As a developer, I can attest that this would be an extremely easy feature to add. It could be done in three steps:

  1. Add to the images context menu the option to "Set as thumbnail".
  2. For the selected image, add an attribute like thumbnail="true" in the Evernote markup.
  3. When displaying a thumbnail, first scan for an image with this attribute. If one is not found, use the current algorithm.

I think the only real hurdle will be testing in all platforms.

 

Many of us have notes clipped from the web with the first or last image usually being the best one for the note. Much of what I clip are tutorials or instructables with photos for each step and most of the time the auto thumbnail is incorrect.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...