macmac

ios (Archived) Notebook Stacks

44 posts in this topic

Is there a way to organize notebooks by stacks on the ipad? On the Mac, notebook stacks are so helpful in organizing my work, but the stacks are lost on ipad. Wading through all the notebooks is difficult and time consuming. Am I missing something? If stacks are not available on the ipad, what have any of you found to help w/ organizing notebooks on the ipad?

Thank you,

Joe

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

Stacks aren't currently available on the iPad - I'm sure they will be soon though.....

Share this post


Link to post

hi joe. there are no stacks in ios. it is an oft-requested feature. i am sure evernote will get around to it someday.

in my case, though, i generally avoid notebooks, except when i want to view something offline. i find the tags to be a much more efficient way of organizing content. others use a combination of notebooks and tags.

there are a lot of organizational schemes, and if you search around on the forums, you will find that this is a frequent topic of conversation. in general, it is probably good to name notes well (i prefer yymmdd + general -> specific keywords) and use a few different tags (general -> specific). I just made a note this morning titled "111119 journal" and because i talked about a meeting i had with a student yesterday i also used the tags "class" (a general tag for any class taken or taught) and "11his101" (a tag specific for the class meaning 2011 history 101).

when searching, if you use "tag:name" you are able to replicate what a folder view would be without actually having to move a note. combine tag searches and you can be even more precise. i have thousands of notes and i easily find anything i am looking for with one search.

Share this post


Link to post

I, too, would like to see Stacks supported in iOS.

I use Awesome Note (AN) for to-do lists in conjunction with Evernote (EN) for synchronization. This adds AN folders as notebooks to EN. On Windows, I can group the AN notebooks into a single stack to keep things neat. But on iOS it becomes somewhat of a wasteland. Sure, I can quickly find something in particular through tags. But sometimes I just want a quick overview of how the stacks, notebooks and notes are organized - especially when I haven't used a certain stack in a while. That's where I find myself waiting until I can get to a workstation client for a clearer perspective.

Share this post


Link to post

Ya, I would really like to see stacks across the board for mobile devices. I got stack support on my android phone (and its awesome), but for work I use my iPad which still doesn't support stacks. With my current structure its almost impossible to find that I'm looking for with my stacks in place. I understand how to move everything around with nested tags, but frankly that isn't they way I want to work and the tag interface isn't any better on the iOS apps. I love evernote, but I'm really disappointing this feature is taking so long to come around. It seems very fundamental to me.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

i am not a big fan of note stacks, but i have to say that if this kind of fundamental organizational feature is available on one platform, it ought to be made available on others. the same argument goes for nested tags.

Share this post


Link to post

Evernote's often stated aim is to get all functionality across all platforms - however this is a time consuming process across 14 (i think) platforms. So, Stacks will get to iOS eventually.

Share this post


Link to post

I put my vote in for Notebook Stacks on the iPad/iPhone clients. I am in the process of writing a book using Evernote (which is what initially drove my to Evernote) and have become spoiled to what I see on the Mac and Windows. Really would like to have the same functionality on the iPad/iPhone where I do most of my lookups/reference when out of the office. My uses have now expanded to using it a mobile filing cabinet for tax papers and other docs that I now dont have to worrry about where I put it unless I need the original.

Ron

Share this post


Link to post

Sub-tags would be much more useful than notebook stacks. Tags are more flexible and you can also use tags instead of notebooks.

I personally don't need notebook stacks at all but sub-tags and the ability to copy note links is 2 features I look forward to the most.

Share this post


Link to post

Stacks would actually be more useful. Notebook stacks have functionality: you can use a stack as search context. Nested tags are only for organizational tidiness; there is no semantic carryover from the implied hierarchy.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

Having said all that I do use evernote on iPad 99% of the time and organize all information there without using sub-tags. It's possible too. There are workarounds.

But it sure would make the whole process a lot better if I could use them. Basically 2 features that I need are sub-tags and to copy note links. Then it's perfect in terms of I wouldn't have to use workarounds. I don't care about notebook stacks. I'm sure even if notebooks stacks are more useful to some people that they could also replace them with tags and sub-tags

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

Having said all that I do use evernote on iPad 99% of the time and organize all information there without using sub-tags. It's possible too. There are workarounds.

ROFL

You do keep beating that drum. But, at least it is now muted with a dose of making things work anyway. :)

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

I think you'd be pretty much incorrect if you concluded that I haven't thought about the idea of subtags. Plenty of evidence to the contrary in the forums, should you care to search for it.But we're not talking about whether semantically meaningful tag trees would be useful, we're talking about whether stacks should be made available to iOS Evernote clients.

I honestly can't tell if what you're saying describes Evernote as it is today, or the Evernote of your dreams. Or if you're just kidding. Your 'very simple example' sheds no light on the topic, as best I can tell (maybe you use some special meaning of 'simple' of which I was not previously aware). Fact is, I don't see any tags anywhere in your chart. Honestly, your chart reminds me of the ones I see in meetings, which are used to 'prove' that the bosses have thought deeply about some topic (or that their underlings have), and now they have a pretty picture, devoid of actual implementation realities, that they can then point to, and then roll up into a tight bundle and swat you. Yeah, they look great in the PowerPoints, but they slowly sink to the bottom of your stack of project documents when you're actually trying to get the darn thing to work.

Anyways, here in the Evernote of the present-day (50 years down the line, we may all look back and laugh faintly), there really is no intrinsic semantic content inherent in the parent tag / subtag relationship. There are no facilities to connect them together in searching / filtering, as there are with stacks and their contained notebooks, for example. Any semantic content for searching comes from content you add yourself, by making use of naming tricks.

That there could be a semantic connection is of course the subject of occasional hot debate. I'd agree that they could be useful, and to that end, I've even proposed a few concrete suggestions as to how they might be made more useful. But none of that exists today.

But in the context, yes, I would prefer that stacks (which do exist in present-day Evernote) be made available for iOS ciients (bringing them up to par with other clients), rather than waiting for semantically aware tag trees, which do not exist anywhere in Evernote at this time, and which would be a complex undertaking (it's a fundamental change to how tags operate after all, and would affect saved searches, which are persisted across all clients), and which probably wouldn't be available in any near-term time frame.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

But in the context, yes, I would prefer that stacks (which do exist in present-day Evernote) be made available for iOS ciients (bringing them up to par with other clients), rather than waiting for semantically aware tag trees, which would be a complex undertaking (it's a fundamental change to how tags operate after all, and would affect saved searches, which are persisted across all clients), and which probably wouldn't be available in any near-term time frame.

Agreed. Client feature parity is a stated current priority at Evernote. Stacks are obviously around to stay and need to get out to all the clients.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

OK, so there was a fair amount of shaggy dog before the punch line. -_-

Share this post


Link to post

Notebook stacks? Sub-tags? Sure. I doubt there is anyone deeply opposed to having either of these on the iPad. The more parity we have across platforms the better. I wouldn't use either of them myself, but I can certainly see why someone would.

Do we really want to argue about which one is more useful? My answer would be neither :)

Share this post


Link to post

Notebook stacks? Sub-tags? Sure. I doubt there is anyone deeply opposed to having either of these on the iPad. The more parity we have across platforms the better. I wouldn't use either of them myself, but I can certainly see why someone would.

Do we really want to argue about which one is more useful? My answer would be neither :)

They aren't equally useful.

Everything you can do with notebooks could also be done with tags (except local storage but you don't need stacks for that). However you can't replace tags with notebooks. So this is why sub-tags would be more useful than notebook stacks.

Share this post


Link to post

I don't find sub tags useful. I don't find sub notebooks useful. Hence, my answer: neither.

Share this post


Link to post

After giving this topic a lot more thought and looking at all approaches to using tags and sub-tags in evernote which I could think of - I changed my mind about sub-tags and tend to agree with Jefito now.

The more I think about this topic the more I see that stacks aren't all that useful at all considering the way evernote doesn't have true sub-tags and you have to rely on naming conventions to encode hierarchies into tag names and then use search.

Here is an example to explain what I mean

Book

Bk-Fiction

Bk-NonFiction

Bk-Romance

BK-SciFi

To find all books search for tag:Bk* instead of looking in a parent tag "Book"

If evernote treated sub-tags as true sub-tags then whenever you applied Bk-Fiction tag for example all parent tags like "Book" would get applied automatically. In this case sub-tags would've been useful. However the way evernote works currently sub-tags aren't really useful.

You could still apply all parent tags manually but it's just more work compared to using naming conventions. The results would be exactly the same, you're just going to use different ways to find stuff. Applying all parent tags manually gives no benefit and just takes a lot more work.

So you have to use naming conventions. I actually don't see it as a problem at all except sometimes tag names would get too long to be readable on iPad.

As long as you use naming conventions all tags and sub-tags are sorted nicely in the tag list so sub-tag functionality would be useful only to make this list easier to scroll by collapsing some stuff.

I explained why I don't find notebook stacks useful in my above posts.

So the bottom line is after giving this topic a lot more thought I find that stacks aren't really useful at all considering the way evernote currently works.

Real sub-tags would be useful but this would be a different feature request.

Jefito was right on for the most part in his posts in this topic. It'd still be more useful to organize tags in stacks instead of notebooks but that's not the point.

Edited by May
1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

WHAT!? I think I deserve credit for this too :D

"Do we really want to argue about which one is more useful? My answer would be neither."

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post

Evernote is one such software which changes the way you use it.. I like my notes to be stacked.. someone else prefers them to be organized by tags, someone witha combination of stacks and tags. I have been using Evernote on Web, Desktop and my Android phone. Where I have stacked my notes, I would like to seem the same on iPad too. On iPad without stacks it appears as all together a new application.. More than often I pick up my iPad to search for some notes and in 2 seconds I get pissed off and turn to my small screen android device.

So i request Evernote to provide stacking as an option in iPad version of Evernote. For me without it is almost un useable.. and to be honest I am looking for alternatives like OneNote from Microsoft. Only the price tag is keeping me away :P I like applications to be consistent..

my 2C

Share this post


Link to post
So i request Evernote to provide stacking as an option in iPad version of Evernote. For me without it is almost un useable.. and to be honest I am looking for alternatives like OneNote from Microsoft. Only the price tag is keeping me away :P I like applications to be consistent..

Evernote aims for consistency across platforms (sometimes it's not possible due to platform constraints), but the different teams operate independently, and there can be a lag in delivery of like functionality. I'm pretty sure that this issue is on the iOS list; it's already available on Android.

Share this post


Link to post

So the bottom line is after giving this topic a lot more thought I find that stacks aren't really useful at all considering the way evernote currently works.

May, I understand that you don't find Stacks useful.

However, that does NOT mean they "aren't really useful at all".

There are a number of users who have posted in other threads that they prefer to include Notebooks in their organization.

When you use NB, Stacks can be quite helpful.

For example, I might want to setup each of my Projects as a separate NB.

Then, I might want to have a Stack named "Projects" to contain all of these NB.

Then I can use the Search term "stack:Projects" (along with other terms) to limit my search to my projects.

In the EN Win and EN Mac UI, notebooks are displayed within Stacks, making it easier to select.

I don't want to get into a debate of NB vs Tags here -- that has been exhaustively debated elsewhere.

Stacks and Notebooks are just one more option of how to organize Evernote Notes.

Share this post


Link to post

JM, I was actually talking about sub-tags, not notebook stacks...

Notebook staks do have additional functionality, as you mention.

1 person likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.