Jump to content
  • 4
gewappnet

Future of Penultimate?

Idea

There were no updates of Penultimate for a year now although there are lots of open issues:

  • Insufficient support for Apple Pencil: It is still possible to leave marks with the hands. The input should be Pencil only - like it is in GoodNotes - to avoid any unwanted marks.
  • Leaving the app (to the homescreen, to another app) and going back will bring you always to another page of the current note. Very annoying!
  • Lasso cut & paste leaves marks.

But on the other hand the functionality of Penultimate is not integrated fully in Evernote. So is there any future for Penultimate? Will there be any further updates? With the new iPad Pros and iOS 11 Apple Pencil became essential for note taking. As a subscriber of Evernote Premium I would like to know what is the answer of Evernote to this development.

 

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post

28 replies to this idea

Recommended Posts

  • 1
On 19.6.2017 at 2:00 PM, DTLow said:

My preference is the Noteability app.  It supports a blend of typing, handwriting, and sketching

I'm also looking at Goodnotes which has an OCR feature

I'm not concerned much with automatic syncing.  The share menu makes it easy to save into Evernote in native or pdf format

But handwriting in PDFs is not recognized and indexed in Evernote, right? I could go with Notability, but what's the point of uploading manually each note to Evernote if it is not even searchable?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 1
18 hours ago, gazumped said:

Sorry,  but it's unusual for the team to post any comments about current or future developments.  If you can raise a support ticket you'll get some personal feedback which might help...

As you wrote this, I was already in the process of chatting with support and getting answers in a formal ticket.  I appreciate Skylar's response (below), but it seems rather boiler-plate.  I mean according to the previous discussions in the past, these have been "known" issues for OVER A YEAR!  😲

From: support-webform@evernote.com
Subject: Ticket# 2774912 - Chat with Evernote on 2/11/2019
Date: February 11, 2019 at 3:36:51 PM CST

Skylar (Evernote Help and Learning)
Just following up after our chat, thank you for your patience.
To clear, these questions are associated with Penultimate, correct?

1) When using the select too, cutting or moving the selection causes it to leave artifacts behind that you have to then erase yourself.
This is known issue, I don't have an ETA of when it will be resolved, I can assure you we're working diligently to fix it.

2) No support for premium users.. with more than 250 notebooks.
Yes, at this time notebooks limit is 250 on Penultimate, but we are trying to increase more notebooks later, also I don't have an ETA of when it will be increase.

3) if you leave the app, and come back, your place in your notebook is lost, you have to figure out where you were.
Yes, This also known issue too. I can assure you we're working diligently to fix it.

4) Dynamic picture support? Once an image or photo is placed, you can not "edit" it, crop it, etc.. you can only place it.
This feature is not yet available, but I can see how a great addition to Evernote this feature would be and I think other users would find it helpful. I am happy to submit this as a feature request to our development team!

Evernote has always relied on our invested community in order to create a better product by actively listening to our users and their experiences.  While we are eager to implement these requests into action, we still operate on a small base of operations. Please understand that your input is being heard, and we hope to present you with an effective solution soon.  In the meantime, another great resource is our Evernote User Forum, where you and other users can join in the discussion, suggest new feature ideas, and vote for them. Our development team regularly reviews feedback submitted through our Forums in hopes of creating the best product and experience for our users.  At this time, I’m going to close your ticket. If you would like an update on where we are in the progress of this issue, please reply back to us and we will update you accordingly.  We are sorry for inconvenience and appreciate your cooperation.

I guess it is up to you Evernote community!  If you want these fixed, we will need to make sure there is enough interest in having this done, to move it closer on their radar.  Please submit tickets to Evernote with the issues above.  Feel free to add your own to the list. 

Edited by Greg Jewett
Bring specific text to more attention. Action items in red.
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Hi.  I think most folks use alternative apps now,  so with their recent history of cutting back on anything that doesn't support the 'core product' of storing and finding information Penultimate might be under some threat..  but by the same token Evernote have been re-coding their editor software for a couple of years now,  which (kind've) explains any lack of movement on Penultimate:  why develop two editors when you could merge the coding into one structure and make the feature an integral part of the overall product.

Clearly only Evernote knows what they plan,  but since explaining their future plans is a free gift of business intelligence to every competitor,  they tend not to do that.  You may get some response if you reach out to Support - directly if you're a paying customer on https://help.evernote.com/hc/requests/new or tweet them if not via https://twitter.com/evernotehelps

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
44 minutes ago, gazumped said:

Hi.  I think most folks use alternative apps now,

But which one? My understanding is that no third party app offers automatic syncing with Evernote (since the restriction on the API was introduced in 2012). So what is the intended way of taking handwritten notes (with Apple Pencil) in Evernote? Sketches within Evernote? Penultimate? Another app?

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
3 hours ago, gewappnet said:

But which one? My understanding is that no third party app offers automatic syncing with Evernote (since the restriction on the API was introduced in 2012). So what is the intended way of taking handwritten notes (with Apple Pencil) in Evernote? Sketches within Evernote? Penultimate? Another app?

My preference is the Noteability app.  It supports a blend of typing, handwriting, and sketching

I'm also looking at Goodnotes which has an OCR feature

I'm not concerned much with automatic syncing.  The share menu makes it easy to save into Evernote in native or pdf format

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Could not agree more with you, @gewappnet. Penultimate automatically adds pages when you get to the end of the current one, and supports multiple page types, making it better than Evernote's "sketch", which is meant for a single-page sketch. And Penultimate's integration with Evernote, such that it is, is still better than any other note-taking apps' integration with Evernote. But the defects are seriously mounting.

@DTLow you've mentioned two features: OCR (and evernote's full text search) as well as autosync. Taking the whole package, I find Evernote/Penultimate is still more convenient for my use cases than Noteability and Goodnotes for longform note taking.

If Evernote is going to deprecate Penultimate, then they absolutely should open the API back up to the likes of Noteability/Goodnotes. It would mean more Premium subscriptions, surely.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
16 minutes ago, gewappnet said:

But handwriting in PDFs is not recognized and indexed in Evernote, right? I could go with Notability,

That's true, Evernote indexes handwriting in image files; not pdf files

>>but what's the point of uploading manually each note to Evernote if it is not even searchable?

I upload my data to Evernote because this is my vehicle for filing
If I need to find a document/data, I know I've stored it in Evernote

I've had limited success with handwriting OCR; possibly a  reflection of my poor handwriting
My process is

  • rely on intitle search; I make sure my titles are descriptive
  • transcribe my notes into typed content 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I have the same problem. As a teacher I like to plan my lessons with handwriting notes. The missing sync drives me crazy. Tried so many Apps. Writing in Evernote with pencil doesn't feel good. Since a few days I have a new workflow.

Writing notes in MyScript Nebo (handwriting / pencil) -> export my notes as word document to Evernote -> it automatically transform my writing notes (99,9% perfect) into typed text, so I can edit this exported document with words. 

Not perfect. But ok.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
23 minutes ago, Andi123 said:

I have the same problem. As a teacher I like to plan my lessons with handwriting notes. The missing sync drives me crazy. Tried so many Apps. Writing in Evernote with pencil doesn't feel good. Since a few days I have a new workflow.

Writing notes in MyScript Nebo (handwriting / pencil) -> export my notes as word document to Evernote -> it automatically transform my writing notes (99,9% perfect) into typed text, so I can edit this exported document with words. 

Not perfect. But ok.

Thanks for the headsup!  Good looking app - would like to try it out but the Play store says it's incompatible with my Note 4 :(

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
6 minutes ago, gazumped said:

Thanks for the headsup!  Good looking app - would like to try it out but the Play store says it's incompatible with my Note 4 :(

I think this thread is still about a replacement of Penultimate and handwriting with Apple Pencil. So per definition not for Android.

 

I tried Notability and GoodNotes and I think GoodNotes is currently the best Penultimate replacement. It includes a handwriting indexing and the exported PDFs include the recognized text as well, so they are searchable in Evernote. But of course the actual exporting of each note(book) to Evernote needs many taps. I really hope Penultimate is not completely dead and Evernote will come up with a update with complete Pencil support.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
1 hour ago, gewappnet said:

I think this thread is still about a replacement of Penultimate and handwriting with Apple Pencil. So per definition not for Android.

 

I tried Notability and GoodNotes and I think GoodNotes is currently the best Penultimate replacement. It includes a handwriting indexing and the exported PDFs include the recognized text as well, so they are searchable in Evernote. But of course the actual exporting of each note(book) to Evernote needs many taps. I really hope Penultimate is not completely dead and Evernote will come up with a update with complete Pencil support.

I also just discovered that with GoodNotes you can select your handwritten text, and it will convert it into typed text. You can then use the share button to import into Evernote.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
11 minutes ago, sa3oud said:

I also just discovered that with GoodNotes you can select your handwritten text, and it will convert it into typed text. You can then use the share button to import into Evernote.

Yes, but it is not needed. As I said, the normal PDF that is generated by GoodNotes contains the graphics of the writing AND the text. That's why the text of the handwritten PDF from GoodNotes is searchable in Evernote.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
1 hour ago, sa3oud said:

I also just discovered that with GoodNotes you can select your handwritten text, and it will convert it into typed text. You can then use the share button to import into Evernote.

My opinion is that Notability is more polished, but I use GoodNotes for its OCR feature.

I need to make corrections to the converted text because of my poor handwriting

On my iPad Pro, I open two window and transcribe my handwriting section by section.  For me, GoodNotes does 75% of the work in converting writing to text

 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

NoteShelf seems to be the only other handwriting app with full Evernote sync. So it is still possible for third party apps!

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
On 2017-06-22 at 1:54 PM, gewappnet said:

Yes, but it is not needed. As I said, the normal PDF that is generated by GoodNotes contains the graphics of the writing AND the text. That's why the text of the handwritten PDF from GoodNotes is searchable in Evernote.

You are right, it is actually more productive to export to pdf. I also noticed that you can export the document as a good notes document and save it into evernote. This is useful if you are still working on a task and want to add to your handwritten note.  So many possibilities when using both applications.

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
On 6/19/2017 at 12:55 PM, gewappnet said:

Leaving the app (to the homescreen, to another app) and going back will bring you always to another page of the current note. Very annoying!

Lasso cut & paste leaves marks.

I just opened a bug report for the first one, was just about to open the second one for leaving marks, when I found this. So this has been brought to attention half a year ago and not fixed? The latest update (Dec 19, 2017) says it fixed writing in portrait mode offset. So something seems to be happening at least, but not these issues. Evernote, what do we have to do so you fix these other bugs? Showing the wrong page is the worst thing ever and doesn't seem to be a fix that would take more than a day. Please, fix this.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just pinging!  Has anyone heard anything from Evernote regarding the future of Penultimate?  I love it, but all the issues outlined above have not been fixed and with no updates in over a year usually it is on life-support and about to be discontinued.  It will work until it doesn't!   I really hope this is not the case here.   Evernote team?

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
2 hours ago, Greg Jewett said:

I really hope this is not the case here.   Evernote team?

Sorry,  but it's unusual for the team to post any comments about current or future developments.  If you can raise a support ticket you'll get some personal feedback which might help...

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

There's also a voting button at the top left of this page - the higher the number....

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
39 minutes ago, Greg Jewett said:

"I can assure you we're working diligently to fix it."

Wow, that is a new level of denial on their side if they think we'll buy that.

45 minutes ago, Greg Jewett said:

Please submit tickets to Evernote with the issues above.

Haha, this almost makes me want to open a new ticket every time I drag a selection and black dots remain and every time I re-open the app and it's on some random location in between pages. Do you think I can get banned for sending in a new ticket every day? 😆

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
9 minutes ago, Matej 'Retro' Jan said:

Do you think I can get banned for sending in a new ticket every day?

Ever hear of the Boy Who Cried Wolf?  Be a shame if/ when you get a real issue that you need help with... 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Last I checked crying wolf meant giving false alarm, which doesn't apply here since the bugs/issues are real. And if they can't fix even the smallest of bugs, I'm not sure what good it would do me when an even more serious issue came up.

But that's besides the point, since it was a joke.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Just to follow up on the alternatives: NoteShelf 2 is really what Penultimate was supposed to be. It has the exact same Evernote sync functionality as Penultimate (read-only notes that are automatically updated), but it has full Apple Pencil support and more or less everything GoodNotes and Notability offer. If you are still waiting for a proper update of Penultimate wait no longer and go for NoteShelf 2.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

Agree gewappnet, Noteshelf 2 plays very well with EN. In particular with the sync,  searching for content or any minute detail via EN is a breeze. 

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0

I have dumped Penultimate.   I have moved over to NoteShelf 2.   I have not looked back!  It works fantastic with the new iPad and Apple Pencil.   Ignores other movements and touches, only writes with the pencil, copy and paste works, note organization is ok, and a good tool.   If you are tied of waiting on Evernote to fix Penultimate .. this is the tool to move to!

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
  • 0
Posted (edited)

Just looked at their website..it looks great so I'm going to do the same by the looks of it.  Sad really but I ain't waiting any longer!

Update:  Now using Noteshelf2 - Its awesome.  Bye penultimate. 

Edited by DeanM.
Update

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...