Lemayp's post in CTRL + Click: Copy Internal Link was marked as the answer
This is resolved inside of 10.2.4.
Immediately after installing the new version I tried it. For some reason, it was alway giving me an URL that looks like "evernote:///view/1872691/s16/...." regardless of the first or second option I use. After few minutes, it start to work properly, consistently. I am not sure why.