Frugal Strong, I just switched devices since my old phone broke. I installed the Evernote app and I experienced the same exact thing. When I installed the app on my new phone it had me sign, so I entered the email address I thought I originally created the app with. It didn't tell me the account didn't exist it just made me request a new password (since I was entering the password for the initial account.) Since it didn't tell me I didn't already have an account I assumed that was the email address I used. I uninstalled and reinstalled the app, tried another email address and viola, all my notes appeared. Is there ANY possibility that you opened your account under a different email address? I really hope so!!! Good luck!