Steps to duplicate the problem:
Highlight from the text starting with '* I am' at the bottom of the last picture.
Highlight to the end of the 'many notes' section
Sync, Open new Note
Contents will be intact and formatting preserved and will look like this:
Change '4 large egg yolks' to '5 large egg yolks'
Formatting is lost and now looks like this:
I am currently sending clips to Evernote Web.