I just had this problem for the first time on Safari. Right click and Save full page to Evernote works saving the full page with actual formatting, the title of the note being the title of the page. Open the page in Evernote from the Develop menu also works but saves a RTF/text version, the title of the note being the URL of the page. Just choose the one you like until is solved… or forever ETA: PS. forgot to say thanks for the tips!