I had the same issue with Spotlight not searching any of my Evernote content. I was working with the App Store version. Uninstalled it completely then went to Evernote.com and did the download from there. Upon installing I did get a prompt that the install file detected an App Store version but it seems to have overwritten it and my mac is currently reindexing. When I do a Spotlight now, Evernote Notes are showing up in the list. Software versions: OS X 10.8.2, Evernote 5.0.5 (400808) Thanks!